01 / 20

Promissory Estoppel
& Restitution

When a promise is enforceable without consideration because someone reasonably relied on it to their detriment.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Promissory Estoppel?

Ordinarily, a promise is only enforceable as a contract if it is supported by consideration (a bargained-for exchange). Promissory estoppel is a substitute for consideration.

It allows a court to enforce a promise when the promisee reasonably and foreseeably relied on that promise, and injustice can only be avoided by enforcing it.

Key Terms

Promisor
The person who makes the promise that another party relies on.
Promisee
The person who hears the promise and reasonably acts in reliance on it.
Detriment
The cost, expense, or position change the promisee suffers by relying.

How Reliance Creates Liability

Promisor makes a promise Promisee relies & acts Court enforces to avoid injustice Detrimental reliance bridges the gap where consideration is missing

The Rule (Restatement § 90)

In essence, the remedy may be limited as justice requires — courts can enforce the promise fully or award only reliance damages.

The Four Elements

1
A promise. A clear, definite promise must have been made.
2
Reasonable expectation of reliance. The promisor should foresee that the promise would induce action or forbearance.
3
Actual reliance. The promisee in fact relied to their detriment.
4
Injustice avoidable only by enforcement. Fairness requires the court to enforce the promise.

Estoppel vs. Consideration

True Contract
Requires a bargained-for exchange. Each side gives and receives something of legal value.
Promissory Estoppel
No exchange needed. The promisee's reliance substitutes for consideration.

Restitution & Unjust Enrichment

Restitution is a separate, quasi-contractual remedy. It does not require a promise at all. It applies where one party confers a benefit on another and it would be unjust for the recipient to keep it without paying.

How to Apply It

1
Look for missing consideration. If a valid contract exists, use contract law first.
2
Identify the promise. Was it clear and definite, not mere puffery?
3
Test foreseeability and reliance. Was reliance reasonable, foreseeable, and actual?
4
Assess the remedy. Award expectation or reliance damages as justice requires.

Example 1: The Charitable Pledge

Donor promises a university \( \$50{,}000 \) to build a library wing. Relying on the pledge, the university begins construction. Donor then refuses to pay.

Example 2: The Subcontractor Bid

A subcontractor submits a bid of \( \$20{,}000 \) for electrical work. The general contractor uses that bid to calculate its own bid and wins the project. The sub then tries to revoke.

Example 3: No Reliance Damages

An uncle promises his niece \( \$1{,}000 \) "just because." She is delighted but does not change her position or spend anything in reliance.

Common Mistakes

✕ Skipping reliance
Claiming estoppel without actual, detrimental reliance by the promisee.
✕ Ignoring foreseeability
Forgetting that the promisor must reasonably expect to induce the reliance.
✕ Confusing remedies
Restitution measures the benefit conferred; estoppel measures reliance or expectation.

Side-by-Side Summary

Promissory EstoppelRestitution
Requires a promise?YesNo
Requires consideration?NoNo
Key triggerDetrimental relianceUnjust enrichment
Measure of recoveryReliance / expectationValue of benefit

Question 1 of 5

Promissory estoppel is best described as a substitute for which contract element?

Question 2 of 5

Which element is required for a promissory estoppel claim?

Question 3 of 5

A restitution claim measures recovery by:

Question 4 of 5

What is the strongest theory to bind the subcontractor?

Question 5 of 5

An uncle promises his nephew \( \$5{,}000 \) as a gift. The nephew never spends or changes his position in reliance. The uncle refuses to pay. Which is correct?

Key Takeaways

1
Estoppel substitutes for consideration when there is detrimental reliance.
2
Remember the four elements: promise, foreseeability, reliance, injustice.
3
Restitution needs no promise — it remedies unjust enrichment by the benefit conferred.
4
Match the remedy to the theory: reliance/expectation vs. value of the benefit.