01 / 20

Products Liability
Defective Products

Learn how to identify defective products and hold sellers responsible under strict liability, negligence, and warranty theories.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Products Liability?

Products liability is the body of law holding commercial sellers responsible for injuries caused by defective products they place into the stream of commerce.

The Stream of Commerce

Manufacturer builds product Distributor ships product Retailer sells product Injured Consumer

Three Types of Defects

Manufacturing
Product differs from intended design — a flaw on the assembly line.
Design
The entire product line is dangerous as designed; a safer alternative existed.
Warning
Inadequate instructions or failure to warn of non-obvious risks.

Strict Liability: The Elements

1
Defendant is a commercial seller of the product (merchant who deals in such goods).
2
Product was defective when it left the defendant's control.
3
Defect caused the injury — both actual and proximate cause.
4
Plaintiff suffered damages to person or property.
5
No substantial alteration of the product after it left the seller.

Testing for a Design Defect

Most courts apply the risk-utility test. A product is defectively designed when the foreseeable risks could have been reduced by a reasonable alternative design. Conceptually:

Three Theories of Recovery

Strict Liability
No fault needed. Focus is on the product, not the seller's conduct.
Negligence
Plaintiff must show the seller breached a duty of reasonable care.
Warranty
Breach of implied merchantability or express promise about the goods.

How to Analyze a Problem

1
Identify the defendant. Is the defendant a commercial seller in the chain of distribution?
2
Classify the defect. Manufacturing, design, or failure to warn?
3
Apply the right test. Risk-utility for design; adequacy for warning defects.
4
Prove causation and damages, then check defenses (misuse, alteration, assumption of risk).

Example 1: Manufacturing Defect

A soda bottle leaves the plant with an unusually thin wall — a single bottle that deviated from the intended design. It shatters in a customer's hand.

Example 2: Design Defect

A power saw has no blade guard. A safer, equally functional model with a low-cost guard was available. A user's hand is cut.

Example 3: Warning Defect

A medication causes severe interactions when combined with alcohol, but the label gives no warning. A patient who drinks suffers harm.

Common Mistakes

✕ Suing a casual seller
Strict liability needs a commercial seller — not a private one-time sale.
✕ Ignoring alteration
Substantial post-sale changes can break causation and defeat the claim.
✕ Confusing the defects
Manufacturing differs from design; pick the correct test for each.
✕ Warning the obvious
No duty to warn of open and obvious dangers a user already knows.

Summary Comparison

Strict LiabilityNegligence
Fault requiredNoYes
FocusThe productSeller's conduct
Privity neededNoNo
DefensesMisuse, alterationComparative fault
Who can be liableAny commercial sellerThe careless party

Defenses to Remember

Product Misuse
Use that was unforeseeable bars or reduces recovery.
Assumption of Risk
Knowing, voluntary encounter with the danger.
Comparative Fault
Plaintiff's own negligence reduces damages in many states.

Question 1 of 5

A new toaster catches fire because one unit's wiring was improperly soldered, unlike all others off the line. Which defect is this?

Question 2 of 5

Under strict products liability, which is NOT required?

Question 3 of 5

A ladder lacks a low-cost stabilizing foot that a safer alternative design used. A user falls. What test applies?

Question 4 of 5

A consumer is injured by a defective blender bought as a gift. The defendant retailer argues the plaintiff never bought it. Best response?

Question 5 of 5

A user removes a saw's blade guard, then is cut. Which defense most likely defeats the strict liability claim?

You've Got the Framework