01 / 20

Privacy Rights

Understand the constitutional and common-law foundations of privacy and learn to apply the doctrine to real fact patterns.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Are Privacy Rights?

Privacy rights protect an individual's interest in controlling personal information, decisions, and spaces from unwanted intrusion. They arise from two distinct sources tested on the bar.

Constitutional Privacy
A liberty interest protecting fundamental personal decisions from government interference.
Common-Law Privacy
Four tort actions protecting individuals from private wrongdoers.

Key Terms

1
Fundamental right: A right "implicit in the concept of ordered liberty" that triggers heightened constitutional scrutiny.
2
State action: Constitutional privacy claims require government conduct, not purely private acts.
3
Reasonable expectation of privacy: The threshold for protection against intrusion or search.

Why It Matters

Constitutional vs. Government 14th Am. liberty Strict scrutiny Marriage, family Common-Law Tort vs. Private parties Damages remedy Four branches Intrusion, etc. Two tracks — identify the right one first

Core Rule: Constitutional Privacy

Fundamental privacy rights recognized by the Court include: marriage, procreation/contraception, family relations, child rearing, and the refusal of medical treatment. Non-fundamental privacy interests receive only rational basis review.

The Four Privacy Torts

1
Intrusion upon seclusion: Prying into private affairs in a manner highly offensive to a reasonable person.
2
Appropriation of likeness: Unauthorized use of a person's name or image for commercial advantage.
3
Public disclosure of private facts: Publicizing private, non-newsworthy facts that are highly offensive.
4
False light: Publicizing facts that place a person in a false light highly offensive to a reasonable person.

False Light vs. Defamation

False Light Defamation
Interest protectedEmotional / dignityReputation
Statement must beHighly offensiveDefamatory
TruthMay still be false lightTruth is a defense
PublicationWide publicityTo one third party

How to Apply the Doctrine

1
Identify the defendant. Government action → constitutional analysis. Private party → tort analysis.
2
Classify the right. Fundamental → strict scrutiny. Non-fundamental → rational basis.
3
Match the tort. Pick which of the four privacy torts the facts satisfy.
4
Check defenses. Consent, newsworthiness, public-record exemptions, or compelling interest.

Worked Example: The Hidden Camera

Facts: A landlord secretly installs a camera inside a tenant's private bathroom. No statement is ever published.

Worked Example: The Endorsement Ad

Facts: A soda company uses a famous athlete's photo on billboards without permission to suggest she endorses their product.

Worked Example: The State Statute

Facts: A state law bans the sale of all contraceptives to married couples. A couple challenges it.

Common Mistakes

✕ Wrong track
Applying tort rules to government action, or constitutional scrutiny to a private dispute.
✕ Requiring publication
Intrusion upon seclusion needs no publication — only prying that is highly offensive.
✕ Ignoring newsworthiness
Forgetting that newsworthiness defeats public-disclosure and false-light claims.

Summary Table

Claim Key Element Main Defense
IntrusionHighly offensive pryingConsent
AppropriationCommercial use of likenessNewsworthiness
Private factsPublic, offensive, privateNewsworthiness
False lightOffensive false impressionImpression is true / Privilege
ConstitutionalFundamental right burdenedCompelling interest

Test Your Understanding

You're ready to apply privacy doctrine. For each question, ask: government or private defendant? Then match the correct rule, element, and defense.

Question 1 of 5

A reporter hacks into a celebrity's phone and reads private texts but never publishes anything. Which tort is most clearly satisfied?

Question 2 of 5

A state law substantially burdens a fundamental privacy right. What standard of review applies?

Question 3 of 5

A magazine truthfully reports that a private citizen was arrested years ago for a now-irrelevant minor offense, causing humiliation. The citizen sues for public disclosure of private facts. What is the strongest defense?

Question 4 of 5

A company uses a private individual's photo in a product advertisement without permission. Which claim best fits?

Question 5 of 5

A newspaper publishes a true photo of a hero but pairs it with a caption falsely implying he committed a crime. He sues for false light. Why might this succeed even though the photo is real?

You've Mastered the Framework

Identify the Track
Government → constitutional. Private party → tort.
Match & Defend
Pick the right rule, then test consent, newsworthiness, and scrutiny.