I'll generate a complete, self-contained HTML slide deck on Prior Inconsistent Statements following the design system exactly. ```html Prior Inconsistent Statements
01 / 20

Prior Inconsistent
Statements

When a witness says one thing now and said something different before, the law has rules about how that earlier statement can be used.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Prior Inconsistent Statement?

A prior inconsistent statement (PIS) is something a witness said or wrote before trial that conflicts with what the same witness now says on the stand.

Two Possible Uses

A PIS can be offered for two very different purposes. The rules treat each one differently:

1. To Impeach
Used only to attack credibility — to show the witness is unreliable. Always allowed.
2. For Its Truth
Used as substantive evidence that the earlier statement is actually true. Allowed only in limited situations.

The Two Pathways

Prior Inconsistent Statement Impeachment Always allowed Substantive Use Needs an exception Jury may use it only to judge whether to believe the witness. Made under oath at a prior proceeding (FRE 801(d)(1)(A)).

The Core Rule

If the prior statement was not under oath at a proceeding (for example, a casual statement to a friend or police), it can still be used to impeach — but not for its truth.

Federal vs. Common Law

Federal (FRE) Traditional Common Law
Used to impeach? Yes Yes
Used for its truth? Yes, if under oath at proceeding No (impeachment only)
Oath requirement Required for substantive use Not applicable

How to Analyze a PIS

1
Identify the inconsistency. Does the prior statement truly conflict with the trial testimony?
2
Determine the purpose. Is it offered to impeach, or for the truth of what was said?
3
For impeachment: generally admissible — no oath required.
4
For its truth: ask whether the statement was made under oath at a proceeding. If yes, it is non-hearsay.

Example 1: Statement to Police

At trial, Wanda testifies "the car was blue." Last year she told an officer "the car was red" — not under oath.

Example 2: Grand Jury Testimony

At trial, a witness says "I never saw the defendant there." But before the grand jury — under oath — he testified "I saw the defendant at the scene."

Example 3: No Real Conflict

At trial, the witness says "I don't remember the exact time." Earlier she had said "It was around 9 p.m."

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing the Two Uses
Assuming any PIS comes in for its truth. Most are limited to impeachment only.
✕ Forgetting the Oath
For substantive use under FRE 801(d)(1)(A), the prior statement must be under oath at a proceeding.
✕ Ignoring Real Inconsistency
If statements don't actually conflict, there's no prior inconsistent statement at all.

Quick Summary

Where the prior statement was made Impeach? For Truth?
Casual remark to a friend ✓ ✕
Statement to police (no oath) ✓ ✕
Grand jury (under oath) ✓ ✓
Deposition (under oath) ✓ ✓

Question 1 of 5

Under the Federal Rules, a prior inconsistent statement may be admitted for its truth only if it was:

Question 2 of 5

A witness testifies at trial. The prosecution offers her earlier statement to a friend that contradicts her testimony, not under oath. What use is permitted?

Question 3 of 5

May the deposition statement be used for its truth?

Question 4 of 5

Which of the following is required before a statement can even qualify as a prior inconsistent statement?

Question 5 of 5

A witness gave sworn grand jury testimony that conflicts with her trial testimony. On the Uniform Bar Exam, what is the best answer regarding admissibility?

The Decision Test

When you spot a prior inconsistent statement on the exam, ask one decisive question for substantive use:

Key Takeaways

1
Impeachment is almost always allowed — no oath required.
2
Substantive use needs the oath at a trial, hearing, proceeding, or deposition.
3
Always confirm real inconsistency before doing anything else.
4
On the UBE, apply the Federal Rules unless instructed otherwise.

You're Ready

You can now evaluate any prior inconsistent statement: confirm the conflict, identify the purpose, and apply the oath-at-a-proceeding test.

``` This complete slide deck covers Prior Inconsistent Statements with all 20 slides, 5 assessment questions, the collapsible passage pattern for the longer question, proper accordion support for the mistakes grid on mobile, full keyboard/touch navigation, and KaTeX integration ready for any math content. The design follows every token, component pattern, and accessibility rule from the system specification.