Prior Inconsistent
Statements
When a witness says one thing now and said something different before, the law has rules about how that earlier statement can be used.
What Is a Prior Inconsistent Statement?
A prior inconsistent statement (PIS) is something a witness said or wrote before trial that conflicts with what the same witness now says on the stand.
Two Possible Uses
A PIS can be offered for two very different purposes. The rules treat each one differently:
The Two Pathways
The Core Rule
If the prior statement was not under oath at a proceeding (for example, a casual statement to a friend or police), it can still be used to impeach — but not for its truth.
Federal vs. Common Law
| Federal (FRE) | Traditional Common Law | |
|---|---|---|
| Used to impeach? | Yes | Yes |
| Used for its truth? | Yes, if under oath at proceeding | No (impeachment only) |
| Oath requirement | Required for substantive use | Not applicable |
How to Analyze a PIS
Example 1: Statement to Police
At trial, Wanda testifies "the car was blue." Last year she told an officer "the car was red" — not under oath.
Example 2: Grand Jury Testimony
At trial, a witness says "I never saw the defendant there." But before the grand jury — under oath — he testified "I saw the defendant at the scene."
Example 3: No Real Conflict
At trial, the witness says "I don't remember the exact time." Earlier she had said "It was around 9 p.m."
Common Mistakes
Quick Summary
| Where the prior statement was made | Impeach? | For Truth? |
|---|---|---|
| Casual remark to a friend | ✓ | ✕ |
| Statement to police (no oath) | ✓ | ✕ |
| Grand jury (under oath) | ✓ | ✓ |
| Deposition (under oath) | ✓ | ✓ |
Question 1 of 5
Under the Federal Rules, a prior inconsistent statement may be admitted for its truth only if it was:
Question 2 of 5
A witness testifies at trial. The prosecution offers her earlier statement to a friend that contradicts her testimony, not under oath. What use is permitted?
Question 3 of 5
At trial in a federal court, witness Dan testifies: "The man who robbed the store was tall and bald."
The defense then offers Dan's prior deposition testimony, given under oath, in which Dan stated: "The robber had a full head of brown hair."
The defense wants the jury to actually believe the robber had brown hair — to prove their client (who is bald) is not the robber.
May the deposition statement be used for its truth?
Question 4 of 5
Which of the following is required before a statement can even qualify as a prior inconsistent statement?
Question 5 of 5
A witness gave sworn grand jury testimony that conflicts with her trial testimony. On the Uniform Bar Exam, what is the best answer regarding admissibility?
The Decision Test
When you spot a prior inconsistent statement on the exam, ask one decisive question for substantive use:
Key Takeaways
You're Ready
You can now evaluate any prior inconsistent statement: confirm the conflict, identify the purpose, and apply the oath-at-a-proceeding test.