01 / 20

Principal Liability
for Agent Actions

When is a principal bound by what its agent does? Master authority, ratification, and vicarious liability.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

The Three Key Players

Agency law governs relationships where one person acts on behalf of another. Liability questions turn on the bonds between these three parties.

Principal (P)
The person who authorizes another to act for them and who may become bound by that conduct.
Agent (A)
The person who agrees to act on the principal's behalf and subject to their control.
Third Party (TP)
The outside party who deals with the agent and seeks to hold the principal liable.

The Agency Triangle

Principal (P) Agent (A) Third Party (TP) authorizes & controls acts / deals LIABILITY?

Two Paths to Liability

Principal liability comes in two distinct flavors. Always identify which path the question is testing before applying rules.

Contract Liability
P is bound to a contract the agent made with a third party. Turns on authority (actual, apparent) or ratification.
Tort Liability
P is liable for the agent's torts. Turns on respondeat superior: was the agent an employee acting within scope?

Three Types of Authority

1
Actual Express Authority. P explicitly tells A what to do, orally or in writing. "Go buy that warehouse."
2
Actual Implied Authority. Authority A reasonably believes they have based on P's conduct, custom, or what is necessary to do the job.
3
Apparent Authority. P holds A out to the third party in a way that makes the TP reasonably believe A is authorized — even if A is not.

Ratification: The After-the-Fact Path

Even when an agent acts with no authority, the principal can become bound by adopting the unauthorized act after it happens.

1
P had capacity at the time of the act and at ratification.
2
P knew all material facts of the transaction.
3
P accepted the entire transaction — cannot ratify only the favorable parts.

Tort Path: Respondeat Superior

An employer is vicariously liable for torts committed by an employee acting within the scope of employment. Two questions:

Employee vs. IC
Is the agent an employee (P controls the manner of work) or an independent contractor (P controls only the result)? P is generally not liable for an IC's torts.
Scope of Employment
Was the tort within the kind of work hired for, during work hours, and serving the employer at least in part?

Actual vs. Apparent Authority

Actual Authority Apparent Authority
Whose belief mattersThe agent'sThe third party's
SourceP's words/conduct to AP's manifestation to TP
Real authority?YesNot required
P bound to TP?YesYes
Lingering after terminationEnds with relationshipMay continue until TP notified

A Step-by-Step Approach

1
Identify the claim type. Is this a contract or a tort question?
2
Confirm an agency exists. Did P manifest assent, A agree to act, and A act subject to P's control?
3
Contract: check actual express, actual implied, apparent authority, then ratification.
4
Tort: employee or IC? If employee, was the act within scope (frolic vs. detour)?
5
Conclude. State clearly whether the principal is bound or liable, and why.

Example 1: Express Authority

Owner tells Manager in writing: "Order up to $5,000 of inventory from any supplier." Manager orders $4,000 of goods from Supplier. Owner refuses to pay. Is Owner bound?

Example 2: Apparent Authority

A car dealership lets Salesperson run the showroom and negotiate prices. Privately, the owner tells Salesperson "never discount below sticker." Salesperson sells a car to a customer at a discount. The customer never knew of the limit. Is the dealership bound?

Example 3: Scope of Employment

A delivery driver, while making deliveries, takes a 2-mile side trip to grab lunch and negligently rear-ends another car. Is the employer liable?

Start Route end 2-mi detour Minor deviation = detour = within scope

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing the audiences
Apparent authority depends on what P said to the third party, not what P told the agent.
✕ Ignoring IC status
Assuming P is liable for every worker's torts. Independent contractors usually break the chain.
✕ Partial ratification
A principal cannot ratify only the good parts of a deal — it is all or nothing.
✕ Mixing contract & tort
Using authority rules to answer a tort question, or scope rules for a contract.

Liability Cheat Sheet

Theory Claim Key Test
Actual expressContractP's explicit instruction
Actual impliedContractReasonable for the job
ApparentContractP's holding-out to TP
RatificationContractKnowing acceptance of all
Respondeat superiorTortEmployee within scope

Test Your Understanding

Five questions ahead. For each fact pattern, ask: contract or tort? Then run the authority or scope analysis you just learned.

Question 1 of 5

A principal explicitly tells his agent: "Sell my house for at least $300,000." The agent signs a contract to sell it for $310,000. Which theory binds the principal?

Question 2 of 5

A store owner publicly introduces an employee as "my purchasing manager." Privately the owner forbids any purchase over $1,000. The employee buys $2,000 of goods from a vendor who knew nothing of the limit. Is the owner bound?

Question 3 of 5

An employee, during work hours and while delivering company packages, drives recklessly and injures a pedestrian. Under what theory is the employer most likely liable?

Question 4 of 5

Can the principal escape the contract?

Question 5 of 5

A homeowner hires a licensed roofing company (an independent contractor) to replace her roof. A roofer negligently drops a tool, injuring a passerby. Is the homeowner liable under respondeat superior?