01 / 20

Preservation of
Jury Trial

How to demand, preserve, and avoid waiving the right to a jury under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

The Seventh Amendment Right

The Seventh Amendment preserves the right to a jury trial in federal civil cases involving claims at law (where money damages are sought). This right does not apply to claims in equity (where injunctions or specific performance are sought).

Claims at Law vs. in Equity

Legal Claims
Seek money damages (e.g., breach of contract, tort). Jury trial right attaches.
Equitable Claims
Seek injunctions, specific performance, rescission. No jury trial right.

The Demand Mechanism

Last Pleading Served Day 0
\( 14 \)-Day Window
File & serve jury demand
Day \( 14 \)
Deadline Waived after

Core Rule: FRCP 38

1
Written demand. The demand must be in writing — orally requesting a jury at a hearing is not enough.
2
Timing. Serve within \( 14 \) days after the last pleading directed to the issue.
3
Filing. File the demand within a reasonable time after service per Rule 5(d).

Scope & Specification of Issues

A party may demand a jury on specific issues only. If the demand specifies issues, the right is limited to those issues — the rest are tried to the judge unless another party demands a jury on them.

Waiver vs. Withdrawal

Waiver (38(d))
Failing to serve and file a timely demand automatically waives the jury right.
Withdrawal
Once made, a proper demand may only be withdrawn with the consent of all parties.

Demand After Removal

When a case is removed from state to federal court, special timing rules apply under FRCP 81(c). If a party expressly demanded a jury before removal, no new demand is required.

How to Analyze Preservation

1
Is there a jury right? Is the claim legal (damages) or equitable (injunction)?
2
Was a written demand made? Check the pleadings and separate papers.
3
Was it timely? Served within \( 14 \) days of the last relevant pleading.
4
Any withdrawal? Confirm no proper waiver or all-party-consented withdrawal occurred.

Relief From Waiver: Rule 39(b)

Even where a party has waived a jury by failing to demand it, the court has discretion under FRCP 39(b) to order a jury trial on motion.

Example 1: Timely Demand

Answer served Day 0 Demand filed Day 10 Deadline
Day \( 14 \)

Example 2: Late Demand

Answer served Day 0 Deadline
Day \( 14 \)
Demand filed Day 20

Example 3: Mixed Claims

Plaintiff sues for both money damages (legal) and an injunction (equitable). Plaintiff makes a proper general jury demand.

Common Mistakes

✕ Oral request
Asking for a jury orally at a hearing does not satisfy the written-demand requirement.
✕ Counting from filing
The \( 14 \)-day clock runs from the service of the last pleading, not from filing the complaint.
✕ Unilateral withdrawal
A demand can only be withdrawn with consent of all parties, not by the demander alone.
✕ Equity = jury
Assuming injunction or specific-performance claims carry a jury right. They do not.

Summary Comparison

Preserved Waived
Type of claimLegal (damages)Equitable only
Form of demandWrittenOral / none
TimingWithin \( 14 \) daysLate / never
WithdrawalAll-party consentFailure to demand
Relief optionAlready timelyRule 39(b) (narrow)

Question 1 of 5

Within how many days after the last pleading directed to the issue must a written jury demand be served under FRCP 38(b)?

Question 2 of 5

A plaintiff sues seeking only a permanent injunction. Does a jury trial right attach?

Question 3 of 5

A party properly demanded a jury. May that party later unilaterally withdraw the demand?

Question 4 of 5

A defendant orally requested a jury at a status conference but never filed a written demand within \( 14 \) days. What is the result?

Question 5 of 5

In a case with both legal and equitable claims and a proper jury demand, what order does the court follow?