Preemption
Analysis
When federal law trumps state law: learn to identify and apply the Supremacy Clause and the doctrines that decide which law controls.
What Is Preemption?
Preemption is the principle that federal law overrides conflicting state law. Its source is the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution, which makes federal law the "supreme Law of the Land."
The Supremacy Hierarchy
Two Kinds of Preemption
The Three Preemption Doctrines
Field Preemption
Field preemption occurs when the federal regulatory scheme is so pervasive or the federal interest so dominant that courts infer Congress meant to occupy the entire field, leaving no room for state regulation.
Conflict Preemption
Field vs. Conflict
| Field | Conflict | |
|---|---|---|
| Trigger | Congress occupies entire area | Direct clash of two laws |
| State law complements? | Still preempted | Allowed if no clash |
| Inquiry | Pervasiveness of scheme | Impossibility or obstacle |
| Type | Implied | Implied |
The Presumption Against Preemption
Courts start with the assumption that Congress did not intend to preempt state law, especially in areas of traditional state police power: health, safety, and welfare.
How to Run a Preemption Analysis
Example 1: Express Language
A federal cigarette-labeling statute states: "No requirement based on smoking and health shall be imposed under State law." A state then enacts a tort claim requiring extra warnings.
Example 2: Field Occupied
A state passes a law letting local police arrest unauthorized immigrants. The federal immigration framework is comprehensive and detailed.
Example 3: Conflict & Obstacle
Federal law approves a drug label and prohibits changes without FDA approval. A state tort theory would require the manufacturer to add a warning the FDA never approved.
Common Mistakes
Preemption Summary
| Type | How Found | Test |
|---|---|---|
| Express | Statutory text | Explicit displacement language |
| Field | Implied | Pervasive federal scheme |
| Impossibility | Implied | Cannot obey both laws |
| Obstacle | Implied | Frustrates federal purpose |
Question 1 of 5
What constitutional provision is the foundation of preemption doctrine?
Question 2 of 5
A state law that merely complements federal regulation is preempted in which scenario?
Question 3 of 5
A manufacturer cannot comply with both the federally-mandated label and a state-required warning. This illustrates:
Question 4 of 5
In areas of traditional state police power, courts apply a presumption that:
Question 5 of 5
Which step should come first in a preemption analysis?