Preclusion
Doctrine
How a final judgment bars relitigation of the same claims and issues. Master claim preclusion and issue preclusion.
Why Preclusion Matters
Litigation has to end somewhere. The preclusion doctrines stop parties from getting endless "do-overs" once a court has already decided a matter.
Two Doctrines, Two Latin Names
The Preclusion Timeline
Claim Preclusion: The Rule
A final judgment on the merits bars the parties from relitigating claims that were raised or could have been raised in that action. Requires three elements:
Issue Preclusion: The Rule
Once an issue is conclusively decided, the same parties cannot relitigate that specific issue. Requires four elements:
Claim vs. Issue Preclusion
| Claim Preclusion | Issue Preclusion | |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Entire claim / cause of action | Single issue |
| Covers issues never raised? | Yes (could have been) | No (must be litigated) |
| Requires same claim? | Yes | No |
| Nonparty may invoke? | Rarely | Often (nonmutual) |
How to Apply It
Example 1: Claim Preclusion
Driver hits Pedestrian. Pedestrian sues for personal injury and wins. Pedestrian later sues the same Driver over the same accident for property damage to her bicycle.
Example 2: Issue Preclusion
In Suit 1, a jury finds the Defendant negligently caused a fire. Passenger A wins. Passenger B was also injured and now sues the same Defendant in Suit 2.
Example 3: Not on the Merits
Plaintiff's first suit is dismissed for lack of personal jurisdiction. Plaintiff refiles the identical claim in a proper court.
Common Mistakes
Element Summary
| Element | Claim | Issue |
|---|---|---|
| Same parties / privity | Required | Bound party only |
| Final judgment on merits | Required | Required |
| Same transaction | Required | Not required |
| Actually litigated | Not required | Required |
| Essential to judgment | N/A | Required |
Quick Recap
Question 1 of 5
Which doctrine bars relitigating claims that could have been raised but were not?
Question 2 of 5
For issue preclusion, the issue decided in the first action must have been:
Question 3 of 5
Plaintiff sued Defendant for breach of a sales contract and the case was dismissed for improper venue. Plaintiff then refiled the identical breach claim in the correct court.
Is the second suit barred by claim preclusion?
Question 4 of 5
A jury in Suit 1 found Defendant negligently caused a bus crash; Passenger A recovered. Passenger B, injured in the same crash, now sues Defendant and wants to use the negligence finding against it.
Which best describes Passenger B's strategy?
Question 5 of 5
Which element is required for claim preclusion but not for issue preclusion?
You're Ready
Spot the prior judgment, confirm it was on the merits, then test the elements of claim and issue preclusion. Finality wins.