01 / 20

Preclusion
Doctrine

How a final judgment bars relitigation of the same claims and issues. Master claim preclusion and issue preclusion.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

Why Preclusion Matters

Litigation has to end somewhere. The preclusion doctrines stop parties from getting endless "do-overs" once a court has already decided a matter.

Two Doctrines, Two Latin Names

Claim Preclusion
Res judicata. Bars relitigating the entire claim that was, or could have been, brought in a prior suit.
Issue Preclusion
Collateral estoppel. Bars relitigating a specific issue already actually litigated and decided.

The Preclusion Timeline

Lawsuit 1 Goes to final judgment on merits judgment Lawsuit 2 Same parties try to relitigate ✕ PRECLUDED

Claim Preclusion: The Rule

A final judgment on the merits bars the parties from relitigating claims that were raised or could have been raised in that action. Requires three elements:

1
Same parties (or those in privity with them) in both suits.
2
Same claim: arising from the same transaction or occurrence (majority test).
3
Valid, final judgment on the merits in the first action.

Issue Preclusion: The Rule

Once an issue is conclusively decided, the same parties cannot relitigate that specific issue. Requires four elements:

1
Same issue of fact or law in both actions.
2
Actually litigated and determined in the first action.
3
Essential to the judgment (not mere dicta).
4
Fairness: the party to be bound had a full and fair opportunity to litigate.

Claim vs. Issue Preclusion

Claim Preclusion Issue Preclusion
ScopeEntire claim / cause of actionSingle issue
Covers issues never raised?Yes (could have been)No (must be litigated)
Requires same claim?YesNo
Nonparty may invoke?RarelyOften (nonmutual)

How to Apply It

1
Identify both lawsuits. Was there a prior action reaching judgment?
2
Check finality on the merits. Dismissals for lack of jurisdiction or venue are not on the merits.
3
For claim preclusion: same parties + same transaction?
4
For issue preclusion: same issue actually litigated, essential, and fair to bind?

Example 1: Claim Preclusion

Driver hits Pedestrian. Pedestrian sues for personal injury and wins. Pedestrian later sues the same Driver over the same accident for property damage to her bicycle.

Suit 1: Injury Pedestrian wins Suit 2: Bike ✕ Barred

Example 2: Issue Preclusion

In Suit 1, a jury finds the Defendant negligently caused a fire. Passenger A wins. Passenger B was also injured and now sues the same Defendant in Suit 2.

Example 3: Not on the Merits

Plaintiff's first suit is dismissed for lack of personal jurisdiction. Plaintiff refiles the identical claim in a proper court.

Suit 1: Dismissed no jurisdiction Suit 2: Proper ✓ Allowed

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing scope
Applying issue preclusion to claims never actually litigated. Issue preclusion needs actual litigation.
✕ Ignoring "merits"
Treating jurisdictional or venue dismissals as preclusive. They are not on the merits.
✕ Privity slip
Forgetting that parties in privity (e.g., successors) are bound just like the original parties.

Element Summary

Element Claim Issue
Same parties / privityRequiredBound party only
Final judgment on meritsRequiredRequired
Same transactionRequiredNot required
Actually litigatedNot requiredRequired
Essential to judgmentN/ARequired

Quick Recap

Question 1 of 5

Which doctrine bars relitigating claims that could have been raised but were not?

Question 2 of 5

For issue preclusion, the issue decided in the first action must have been:

Question 3 of 5

Is the second suit barred by claim preclusion?

Question 4 of 5

Which best describes Passenger B's strategy?

Question 5 of 5

Which element is required for claim preclusion but not for issue preclusion?

You're Ready

Spot the prior judgment, confirm it was on the merits, then test the elements of claim and issue preclusion. Finality wins.