Position Favoring
Factors
Learn to identify the facts, rules, and equities that tilt a dispute toward your client or the opposing party.
What Is a Favoring Factor?
A favoring factor is any fact, legal rule, or equitable consideration that, when applied to the dispute, makes a particular party more likely to prevail.
Three Sources of Factors
Weighing the Scales
The Core Rule
Think of each claim as a set of required elements. We can express whether a party wins on a single element \( E \) as:
$$ \text{Win}(E) = \big(\text{Burden met}\big) \;\wedge\; \big(\text{No valid defense}\big) $$
Mapping Facts to Elements
Favorable Fact vs. Dispositive Fact
A Step-by-Step Approach
Example 1: Breach of Contract
Facts: A signed written contract requires delivery by June 1. The seller delivered on June 10. The buyer suffered \( \$5{,}000 \) in lost profits.
Example 2: Negligence
Facts: A driver ran a red light and struck a pedestrian. The pedestrian was crossing against the "Don't Walk" signal.
Example 3: A Dispositive Factor
Facts: A plaintiff files a personal injury suit. The injury occurred on March 1, 2020. The jurisdiction's limitations period is \( 2 \) years. Suit was filed June 2023.
Common Mistakes
Summary Comparison
| Favors a Party | Neutral / Irrelevant | |
|---|---|---|
| Ties to an element | Yes | No |
| Affects outcome | Yes | No |
| Include in analysis | Always | Note briefly |
| Can be dispositive | Sometimes | Never |
Question 1 of 5
Which best describes a favoring factor?
Question 2 of 5
A plaintiff must prove all four negligence elements. The defendant produces strong evidence defeating causation only. What is the likely result?
Question 3 of 5
Facts: A driver ran a red light and struck a pedestrian who was crossing against the "Don't Walk" signal. The jurisdiction uses comparative negligence.
The pedestrian sues for her injuries. The driver argues the pedestrian should recover nothing because she also violated a traffic signal.
Which fact favors the driver?
Question 4 of 5
A suit is filed three years after the injury where the limitations period is \( 2 \) years and no tolling applies. This expired-limitations fact is best described as:
Question 5 of 5
What is the most common error when identifying position-favoring factors on the bar exam?
Key Takeaways
You're Ready to Balance the Scales
Sort facts, tie them to elements, and weigh both sides to predict the likely outcome with confidence.