Policy
Exclusions
When does an insurance policy not cover a loss? Learn to apply policy-based exclusions and analyze coverage disputes.
What Is a Policy Exclusion?
An insurance policy is a contract. The insuring agreement states broadly what is covered. An exclusion is a contract provision that removes certain risks, perils, or losses from the coverage that would otherwise apply.
The Coverage Funnel
Key Terms
The Core Rule
This reflects the doctrine of contra proferentem: because the insurer drafts the policy, any genuine ambiguity in an exclusion is read against the insurer and in favor of finding coverage.
Burden-Shifting Framework
Exclusion vs. Lack of Coverage
Common Exclusions
How to Apply an Exclusion
Worked Example 1
A homeowner's policy covers "all losses to the dwelling" but excludes "loss caused by flood." A burst water heater floods the basement. The insurer denies the claim, citing the flood exclusion.
Worked Example 2
A liability policy excludes injuries "expected or intended" by the insured. The insured shoves a person, who falls and suffers a far more serious injury than anticipated. The insurer invokes the intentional-act exclusion.
Worked Example 3
An auto policy excludes coverage while the vehicle is "used to carry persons for a fee," but contains an exception for "shared-expense carpools." The insured drove neighbors to work, splitting gas costs, when a collision occurred.
Common Mistakes
Summary Table
| Coverage Grant | Exclusion | Exception | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Effect | Grants coverage | Removes coverage | Restores coverage |
| Burden on | Insured | Insurer | Insured |
| Construed | Broadly | Narrowly | In favor of coverage |
Question 1 of 5
In a coverage dispute, who generally bears the burden of proving that an exclusion applies?
Question 2 of 5
An exclusion clause is genuinely ambiguous. How should a court construe it?
Question 3 of 5
Before applying any exclusion to a claimed loss, what must first be established?
Question 4 of 5
A liability policy covers bodily injury but excludes "injury expected or intended by the insured." During an argument, the insured deliberately pushed another person, intending only to make him step back. The person tripped, fell down a staircase, and suffered a severe head injury far worse than the insured anticipated.
The insurer denied the claim under the intentional-act exclusion. The insured argues the exclusion should not apply because he never intended such serious harm.
How is a court most likely to rule on the exclusion?
Question 5 of 5
An exclusion bars coverage, but the policy contains an exception that would restore it. Who must prove the exception applies?