01 / 20

Performance Excuse
Impossibility & Frustration

When unexpected events strike, may a party be excused from performing? Master impossibility, impracticability, and frustration of purpose.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

The Problem of Broken Promises

Contract law normally enforces a strict rule: a party who fails to perform is in breach and owes damages. But sometimes a supervening event — one neither party foresaw — makes performance pointless or impossible.

These are affirmative defenses to a breach claim. The defendant admits non-performance but argues the law should forgive it.

Three Doctrines of Excuse

Impossibility
Performance has become objectively impossible — no one could do it, not just this party.
Impracticability
Performance is technically possible but only at extreme and unreasonable cost due to an unforeseen event.
Frustration
Performance is still possible, but the purpose for the deal has been destroyed.

The Excuse Decision Path

Supervening Event? Unforeseen, no fault Basic Assumption of Deal? Risk not allocated to this party Impossibility Cannot be done Impracticability Extreme cost Frustration Purpose destroyed Duty Discharged

Doctrine 1: Impossibility

Performance is excused when, after formation, an unanticipated event makes performance objectively impossible — meaning no one could perform, not merely that this particular party cannot.

1
Death or incapacity of a person essential to performance (personal-service contracts).
2
Destruction of the specific subject matter required for performance.
3
Supervening illegality — a new law makes the agreed performance unlawful.

Doctrine 2: Impracticability

A modern relaxation of strict impossibility. Performance is excused when an unforeseen event makes it possible only at extreme and unreasonable difficulty or expense.

Recognized under both the common law (Restatement § 261) and the UCC (§ 2-615) for sale-of-goods contracts.

Doctrine 3: Frustration of Purpose

Here performance is still entirely possible — but a supervening event destroys the reason a party entered the deal, and the other party knew of that purpose.

1
A supervening event substantially frustrates a party's principal purpose.
2
Non-occurrence of that event was a basic assumption on which the contract was made.
3
The frustration was not the fault of the party seeking discharge, and that party did not bear the risk.

Frustration vs. Impracticability

These two are easily confused. The decisive question is whether performance is still useful.

Impracticability
The supplier/performer side. Performing has become extraordinarily burdensome or costly.
Frustration
The recipient/buyer side. Performing is easy, but the deal is now worthless to that party.

A Five-Step Analysis

1
Identify the supervening event that occurred after formation.
2
Ask: was its non-occurrence a basic assumption of the contract?
3
Check fault and foreseeability — the party can't have caused it or assumed the risk.
4
Classify — impossible, merely impracticable, or purpose-destroying?
5
Determine the remedy — full discharge, partial, or restitution for benefits conferred.

Example 1: The Burned Hall

A caterer agrees to provide a banquet at a specific historic hall. One week before, the hall burns down through no one's fault.

Compare: if any equivalent hall would do, destruction of one hall would not excuse — performance would merely be inconvenient.

Example 2: The Parade Room

A tenant rents a balcony room at a premium rate solely to watch a coronation parade. The parade is cancelled when the monarch falls ill. The room is still perfectly usable.

This is the classic Krell v. Henry scenario — the engine of the frustration doctrine.

Example 3: The Cost Spike

A supplier contracts to deliver goods. A sudden shipping crisis raises the supplier's delivery cost by roughly tenfold, but goods can still be obtained.

Cost Normal After Spike
\(\approx 10\times\)

Common Mistakes

✕ Subjective vs. Objective
"I can't afford it" is subjective and does not excuse. Impossibility must be objective — no one could perform.
✕ Cost = Impracticability
Increased expense alone rarely excuses. The hardship must be extreme and from an unforeseen event.
✕ Ignoring Foreseeability
If the event was foreseeable or the risk allocated by the contract, no excuse applies.

Doctrine Comparison

Impossibility Impracticability Frustration
Can it be done?NoYes, but extreme costYes, easily
What's lost?The performanceFeasibilityThe purpose
Whose side?EitherPerformerRecipient
Typical triggerDestruction / deathSevere burdenEvent nullifies value

Question 1 of 5

A famous opera singer contracts to perform but dies the night before. The promoter sues the estate for breach. The estate's best defense is:

Question 2 of 5

A buyer leases space to operate a fireworks stand. After signing, the city bans all fireworks sales. Performance (occupying the space) is still possible. The buyer should argue:

Question 3 of 5

A contractor's supply costs rise 30% due to ordinary market fluctuation. He refuses to perform, claiming impracticability. A court will most likely:

Question 4 of 5

Which element is required by all three excuse doctrines?

Question 5 of 5

The grower's strongest argument is:

Key Takeaways

1
Impossibility — performance objectively cannot be done.
2
Impracticability — possible only at extreme, unforeseen cost.
3
Frustration — possible but the purpose is destroyed.
4
All require a supervening event, a basic assumption, and no fault.