Performance Excuse
Impossibility & Frustration
When unexpected events strike, may a party be excused from performing? Master impossibility, impracticability, and frustration of purpose.
The Problem of Broken Promises
Contract law normally enforces a strict rule: a party who fails to perform is in breach and owes damages. But sometimes a supervening event — one neither party foresaw — makes performance pointless or impossible.
These are affirmative defenses to a breach claim. The defendant admits non-performance but argues the law should forgive it.
Three Doctrines of Excuse
The Excuse Decision Path
Doctrine 1: Impossibility
Performance is excused when, after formation, an unanticipated event makes performance objectively impossible — meaning no one could perform, not merely that this particular party cannot.
Doctrine 2: Impracticability
A modern relaxation of strict impossibility. Performance is excused when an unforeseen event makes it possible only at extreme and unreasonable difficulty or expense.
Recognized under both the common law (Restatement § 261) and the UCC (§ 2-615) for sale-of-goods contracts.
Doctrine 3: Frustration of Purpose
Here performance is still entirely possible — but a supervening event destroys the reason a party entered the deal, and the other party knew of that purpose.
Frustration vs. Impracticability
These two are easily confused. The decisive question is whether performance is still useful.
A Five-Step Analysis
Example 1: The Burned Hall
A caterer agrees to provide a banquet at a specific historic hall. One week before, the hall burns down through no one's fault.
Compare: if any equivalent hall would do, destruction of one hall would not excuse — performance would merely be inconvenient.
Example 2: The Parade Room
A tenant rents a balcony room at a premium rate solely to watch a coronation parade. The parade is cancelled when the monarch falls ill. The room is still perfectly usable.
This is the classic Krell v. Henry scenario — the engine of the frustration doctrine.
Example 3: The Cost Spike
A supplier contracts to deliver goods. A sudden shipping crisis raises the supplier's delivery cost by roughly tenfold, but goods can still be obtained.
Common Mistakes
Doctrine Comparison
| Impossibility | Impracticability | Frustration | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Can it be done? | No | Yes, but extreme cost | Yes, easily |
| What's lost? | The performance | Feasibility | The purpose |
| Whose side? | Either | Performer | Recipient |
| Typical trigger | Destruction / death | Severe burden | Event nullifies value |
Question 1 of 5
A famous opera singer contracts to perform but dies the night before. The promoter sues the estate for breach. The estate's best defense is:
Question 2 of 5
A buyer leases space to operate a fireworks stand. After signing, the city bans all fireworks sales. Performance (occupying the space) is still possible. The buyer should argue:
Question 3 of 5
A contractor's supply costs rise 30% due to ordinary market fluctuation. He refuses to perform, claiming impracticability. A court will most likely:
Question 4 of 5
Which element is required by all three excuse doctrines?
Question 5 of 5
Facts: A grower contracts to sell a buyer 1,000 tons of crops "from my northern field." An unprecedented and unforeseeable flood destroys that entire field, and no comparable substitute is available anywhere.
The grower asserts a performance excuse when sued for non-delivery. Assume no fault and no contractual risk-shifting clause.
The grower's strongest argument is: