Other Acts
Evidence
When can a person's prior bad acts come into evidence? Master the propensity ban and its critical exceptions.
What Is Other Acts Evidence?
Other acts evidence refers to a person's prior crimes, wrongs, or acts offered at trial. The central question is always: what is the evidence being offered to prove?
The Propensity Ban
The Rule: FRE 404(b)
Permitted Purposes: MIMIC
Propensity vs. Non-Propensity
The same evidence can be admissible or inadmissible depending on the chain of reasoning it requires the jury to make.
| Propensity (Banned) | Non-Propensity (OK) | |
|---|---|---|
| Inference | Bad person → likely guilty | Act proves a specific fact |
| Relies on | Character of the actor | Logical relevance to issue |
| Example use | "He's violent by nature" | "Identity by unique scar" |
| Admissible? | No | Yes (if 403 passes) |
How to Apply the Rule
The 403 Gatekeeper
Example 1: Intent
A defendant is charged with embezzlement and claims the missing funds were an honest accounting error. The prosecution offers evidence that he diverted company money the same way twice before.
Example 2: Identity
Example 3: The Trap
A defendant is charged with assault. The prosecution offers his three prior assault convictions, arguing simply that he "has a history of violence" and is therefore the kind of person who would attack the victim.
Common Mistakes
404(b) Summary
| Step | Question | If Yes |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pure propensity? | Exclude |
| 2 | Fits MIMIC? | Proceed to step 3 |
| 3 | Reasonable jury find act? | Proceed to step 4 |
| 4 | Prejudice ≫ value? | Exclude (403) |
| 5 | All steps clear? | Admit |
Question 1 of 5
Other acts evidence is never admissible to prove which of the following?
Question 2 of 5
A defendant is charged with arson of his own warehouse to collect insurance. The prosecution offers evidence that the defendant filed two suspicious fire-insurance claims for prior buildings he owned that also burned down.
The prior fires are most likely admissible to show:
Question 3 of 5
Even when other acts evidence has a valid MIMIC purpose, it may still be excluded under FRE 403 if:
Question 4 of 5
A defendant is charged with petty theft from a store. The only evidence the prosecution offers of the other act is the defendant's single prior shoplifting conviction, introduced with the argument: "He has done this before, so he did it again."
The prior conviction should be:
Question 5 of 5
For other acts evidence to be admitted, what level of proof is required that the act actually occurred?
Key Takeaways
You've Got 404(b)
Always ask: what is it offered to prove? If the answer is character, exclude it. If it's a MIMIC purpose that survives 403, admit it.