01 / 20

Offer and
Acceptance

Learn how an offer and a valid acceptance come together to form a binding contract.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

The Foundation of a Contract

A contract is a legally enforceable agreement. At its heart is mutual assent: the parties must reach a true "meeting of the minds." This is proven through a valid offer followed by a valid acceptance.

Key Terms

Offeror
The party who makes the offer and has the "power" to set its terms.
Offeree
The party who receives the offer and holds the power to accept.
Mutual Assent
An objective meeting of the minds on the essential terms.

How Assent Forms

Offeror makes OFFER Offeree ACCEPTS Offer Acceptance = CONTRACT FORMED

The Rule: A Valid Offer

An offer is a manifestation of present intent to be bound, communicated to the offeree, with reasonably certain and definite terms.

1
Present intent. Judged objectively, would a reasonable person believe an offer was being made?
2
Definite terms. Identifies parties, subject matter, quantity, and price (or a way to determine them).
3
Communicated. The offer must reach the intended offeree.

The Rule: A Valid Acceptance

An acceptance is an objective manifestation of assent to the terms of the offer, made by a person with the power of acceptance.

Offer vs. Invitation to Deal

True OfferInvitation to Deal
IntentPresent intent to be boundInvites others to make offers
Examples"I will sell you my car for $5,000"Advertisements, price lists, displays
EffectAcceptance forms contractResponse is the actual offer

How to Analyze Formation

1
Find the offer. Identify a manifestation of present intent with definite terms.
2
Check if it's still open. Has it been revoked, rejected, or has it lapsed?
3
Find the acceptance. Did the offeree assent in the manner the offer required?
4
Confirm timing. Was acceptance made while the power of acceptance still existed?

Terminating the Power to Accept

Revocation
Offeror withdraws before acceptance; effective when received.
Rejection
Offeree rejects or makes a counteroffer, ending the original offer.
Lapse
Time stated expires, or a reasonable time passes.

Worked Example 1

Alex says to Bea: "I'll sell you my bicycle for $200." Bea replies: "Sounds great, I accept."

Worked Example 2

Carlos offers: "I'll paint your house for $3,000." Dana replies: "I accept, if you also paint the garage."

Worked Example 3

On Monday, Eve writes: "I'll buy your guitar for $400." On Tuesday, Eve mails: "Never mind, I revoke." On Wednesday, Frank mails his acceptance before reading the revocation.

The Mailbox Rule

Acceptance is generally effective the moment it is dispatched (mailed), not when received — provided a proper method is used.

Common Mistakes

✕ Treating ads as offers
Most advertisements are invitations to deal, not binding offers.
✕ Ignoring counteroffers
A counteroffer rejects and kills the original offer at common law.
✕ Confusing timing rules
Acceptance is effective on dispatch; revocation on receipt.

Quick Summary

ActionWhen EffectiveEffect
OfferOn receiptCreates power to accept
AcceptanceOn dispatchForms contract
RevocationOn receiptEnds power to accept
Rejection / CounterofferOn receiptTerminates offer

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following is required for a valid offer?

Question 2 of 5

An offeree responds to an offer by adding a new material term. At common law, this is treated as a:

Question 3 of 5

Under the mailbox rule, when is an acceptance generally effective?

Question 4 of 5

A store posts a newspaper ad: "Coats for $50." A customer arrives wanting to buy at that price. This ad is most likely:

Question 5 of 5

Which event does not terminate the offeree's power of acceptance?