01 / 20

Objective Feasibility
Analysis

How legal rules shape whether a client's multiple stated goals can actually be achieved.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Feasibility?

A client usually arrives with more than one objective — for example, "I want to keep the property, pay no taxes, and stay out of court." Feasibility analysis asks a single question for each goal:

Legal rules act as constraints. Some objectives are flatly barred by law, some are reachable only at a cost, and some conflict with each other.

Key Terms

Objective
A concrete result the client wants (e.g. retain custody, avoid liability).
Constraint
A legal rule that limits or forbids a result.
Trade-off
Gaining one objective requires giving up part of another.

Objectives Pass Through a Legal Filter

Stated Goals Goal A Goal B Goal C Legal Rules Feasible? A ✓ B ~ cost C ✕ barred

The Core Rule

An objective set \( O = \{o_1, o_2, \dots, o_n\} \) is jointly feasible only if every objective is individually permitted by law and no two required objectives are mutually exclusive:

In words: every objective must clear its legal constraint, and the goals must be compatible with one another. A single barred or conflicting goal can collapse the whole set.

Three Kinds of Legal Constraint

1
Prohibitive. The law forbids the result outright. \( \text{Legal}(o_i) = \text{false} \) — the objective is impossible.
2
Conditional. The result is allowed only if requirements are met (consent, filing, payment). Attainable with cost.
3
Permissive. No rule blocks it. Fully attainable unless it conflicts with another goal.

Distinction: Barred vs. Costly

Legally Barred
No lawful path exists. Advising the client to pursue it would be unethical or futile. The goal must be abandoned or reframed.
Attainable at Cost
A lawful path exists but requires concessions — money, time, consent, or surrender of another goal. The client must weigh the trade-off.

How to Apply It

1
List every stated objective separately and clearly.
2
Identify the governing rule for each objective and classify it: prohibitive, conditional, or permissive.
3
Test for conflicts between objectives — does achieving one defeat another?
4
Report feasibility per objective and propose trade-offs or reframing where needed.

Example 1: A Single Barred Goal

A client wants to (A) sell her business and (B) keep the non-compete clause unenforceable so she can immediately open a rival shop next door, where the clause is valid and reasonable.

A: Sell business ✓ Permissive B: Void the clause ✕ Valid & enforceable A feasible B not feasible

Example 2: Conflicting Goals

A client wants to (A) settle a lawsuit quietly and (B) publicly expose the defendant's wrongdoing in the press. Each is lawful alone.

A: Quiet settle ✓ Lawful B: Go public ✓ Lawful CONFLICT Settlement confidentiality clause forbids public disclosure

Example 3: Costly but Attainable

A client wants to (A) keep the family home, (B) discharge most debts in bankruptcy, and (C) avoid any monthly payments. Under the applicable rules, the home can be retained only if the client keeps paying the secured mortgage.

A — Keep home
Attainable, but conditional on continued mortgage payment.
B — Discharge debts
Attainable for unsecured debts under the rules.
C — No payments
Conflicts with A — keeping the home requires payments.

Common Mistakes

✕ Skipping conflicts
Checking each goal's legality but forgetting goals can defeat each other.
✕ "Barred = costly"
Treating a legally impossible goal as merely expensive to achieve.
✕ All-or-nothing
Declaring the whole plan dead when one reframed goal would work.
✕ Ignoring priority
Not asking which conflicting goal the client values most.

Feasibility Summary

Outcome Lawyer Action
Permissive, no conflictFeasiblePursue directly
ConditionalFeasible at costExplain requirements
Conflicts with another goalNot jointly feasibleHave client prioritize
ProhibitiveBarredReframe or abandon

Let's Practice

The following questions test whether you can apply legal constraints to a client's multiple objectives and report which are attainable, costly, or barred.

Question 1 of 5

An objective set is jointly feasible only when:

Question 2 of 5

A client's goal is allowed only after obtaining a regulatory permit and paying a fee. This goal is best classified as:

Question 3 of 5

What is the correct feasibility conclusion?

Question 4 of 5

A client wants to keep her home and make no payments, but the rule allows retaining a mortgaged home only with continued payment. The best advice is to:

Question 5 of 5

Which statement reflects the most complete feasibility analysis of three stated objectives?

Key Takeaways

1
List each objective and find its governing legal rule.
2
Classify the constraint: prohibitive, conditional, or permissive.
3
Check for conflicts — lawful goals can still be mutually exclusive.
4
Report per objective and surface trade-offs or reframing.