01 / 20

Nuisance
Doctrine

When one person's use of land interferes with a neighbor's use and enjoyment of their own property.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Nuisance?

A nuisance is a tort protecting a person's right to use and enjoy their land free from unreasonable interference. Unlike trespass, it does not require a physical invasion: it covers intangible intrusions like noise, odors, smoke, and vibrations.

Two Types of Nuisance

Private Nuisance
A substantial, unreasonable interference with one person's use and enjoyment of their land. Brought by the affected landowner.
Public Nuisance
An unreasonable interference with a right common to the general public (e.g., public health, safety). Usually brought by the government.

Interference Across the Property Line

property line Defendant (factory) Plaintiff (home) smoke / odor / noise

The Private Nuisance Rule

Substantial
Offensive, inconvenient, or annoying to a normal person in the community. A hypersensitive plaintiff cannot recover.
Unreasonable
The gravity of the harm outweighs the utility of the defendant's conduct — a balancing test.

The Balancing Test

Gravity of the Harm Utility of the Conduct Harm outweighs utility = unreasonable

Nuisance vs. Trespass

Nuisance Trespass
Interest protectedUse & enjoymentPossession
Physical invasion?Not requiredRequired
Typical intrusionNoise, odor, smokePerson or object enters
Substantiality?Must be substantialAny entry suffices
Reasonableness?Must be unreasonableNot weighed

How to Apply the Doctrine

1
Identify the type. Private (one landowner) or public (a right common to the community)?
2
Interference with use/enjoyment. Is there an intangible intrusion or loss of enjoyment?
3
Substantial? Would it offend a normal, reasonable person in the community?
4
Unreasonable? Balance the gravity of harm against the utility of the conduct.
5
Remedy & defenses. Damages or injunction; consider "coming to the nuisance."

Example 1: The Noisy Bakery

A bakery runs dough mixers from 2 a.m. to 5 a.m. every night. The neighbor next door cannot sleep due to the constant grinding noise and vibrations through the shared wall.

Example 2: The Hypersensitive Plaintiff

A neighbor operates a normal porch light at night. The plaintiff has a rare condition making them extremely sensitive to light and demands the light be removed.

Example 3: Coming to the Nuisance

A pig farm has operated in a rural area for 30 years. A developer builds new homes nearby, and the residents then sue the farm for the persistent odor.

Remedies & Defenses

Damages
Money for past and ongoing interference and any reduced property value.
Injunction
Court order to stop or limit the activity, granted after balancing the equities.
Abatement
Limited self-help to remove the nuisance after notice and refusal.

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing with trespass
Nuisance protects use/enjoyment; no physical invasion is needed.
✕ Ignoring "normal person"
Hypersensitive plaintiffs cannot recover for ordinary conduct.
✕ Treating "coming to" as a bar
It is a factor in the balance, not an automatic defense.
✕ Forgetting special harm
A private party suing for public nuisance needs harm different in kind.

Private vs. Public Nuisance

Private Public
Interest harmedOne person's landRight common to public
Who suesAffected landownerGovernment (usually)
Private plaintiff?Yes, the landownerOnly with special harm
TestSubstantial & unreasonableUnreasonable interference
ExamplesOdor, noise next doorBlocked highway, pollution

Question 1 of 5

Which interest does the tort of nuisance primarily protect?

Question 2 of 5

A factory emits odors that bother only a plaintiff with an unusually sensitive nose; a normal person would not be disturbed. Result?

Question 3 of 5

For a private nuisance, courts determine whether the interference is unreasonable by:

Question 4 of 5

A private individual wants to sue over a public nuisance (a blocked public road). They may do so only if:

Question 5 of 5

A homeowner moves next to a long-established quarry and then sues for noise. Under the doctrine of "coming to the nuisance," this fact:

Key Takeaways

1
Use & enjoyment. Nuisance protects enjoyment of land; no physical invasion required.
2
Substantial & unreasonable. Normal-person standard plus a harm-vs-utility balance.
3
Private vs. public. Private parties need special harm to sue over a public nuisance.
4
Coming to the nuisance is a factor, never an automatic bar.