01 / 20

Negligence
Per Se

When breaking a statute automatically establishes breach of duty: applying statutory rules in tort law.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Negligence Per Se?

In an ordinary negligence claim, the plaintiff must prove that the defendant's conduct fell below a reasonable standard of care. Negligence per se is a doctrine that lets a plaintiff borrow a statute or regulation to define that standard.

Negligence Has Four Elements

Duty Breach Causation Damages Statute can establish these

Why It Matters

Easier Proof
No need to argue what a reasonable person would have done: the legislature already defined it.
Stronger Case
A clear statutory violation is persuasive evidence of fault for a jury or judge.
Bar Frequency
A heavily tested torts subtopic: examiners love fact patterns built around safety statutes.

The Core Rule

A statutory violation establishes negligence per se only when both threshold tests are satisfied. Think of it as a conjunction:

The plaintiff must be in the class of persons the statute was designed to protect, and the injury must be of the type of harm the statute was designed to prevent.

The Two-Part Test

Statute violated? start here 1. Class of Persons P among those protected? 2. Class of Harm injury type prevented? Both met = Per Se duty + breach established If either fails, fall back to ordinary negligence

Per Se vs. Evidence of Negligence

Jurisdictions differ on the effect of a statutory violation. Know which approach the question follows.

Negligence Per Se Mere Evidence
Effect of violationConclusive on duty + breachOne factor jury may weigh
Jury roleNo breach questionDecides if reasonable
Majority viewConclusive (rebuttable)Minority approach

How to Apply It

1
Identify the statute. Find a safety statute, ordinance, or regulation the defendant violated.
2
Class of persons. Ask whether the plaintiff belongs to the group the statute aims to protect.
3
Class of harm. Ask whether the injury is the kind of harm the statute was meant to prevent.
4
Check excuses. Determine if the violation is excused (emergency, incapacity, impossibility).
5
Prove causation + damages. These are never supplied by the statute: plaintiff still bears the burden.

Recognized Excuses

Even a clear violation may be excused, defeating negligence per se. Common excuses include:

Emergency
Compliance was unsafe due to a sudden emergency not of the defendant's making.
Incapacity
The defendant was physically unable to comply (e.g., a sudden medical event).
Impossibility
Compliance was impossible despite reasonable diligence and care.

Example 1: The Speeding Driver

A driver speeds through a school zone (violating a 25 mph limit) and strikes a child crossing the street. Does negligence per se apply?

Class of Persons ✓ child = protected group Class of Harm ✓ pedestrian collision
\( \wedge \)

Example 2: Wrong Type of Harm

A statute requires shipowners to keep animals penned to prevent the spread of disease. A storm sweeps unpenned sheep overboard, drowning them. The owner sues the carrier.

Class of Persons ✓ livestock owner Class of Harm ✕ drowning ≠ disease
\( \wedge \)

Example 3: An Excused Violation

A statute requires headlights at night. A driver's lights suddenly fail without warning despite recent inspection, and a collision follows in the dark. Negligence per se?

Lesson: even when both threshold tests pass, always screen for a recognized excuse before concluding per se applies.

Common Mistakes

✕ Skipping causation
Per se only supplies duty and breach. Plaintiff must still prove actual and proximate cause plus damages.
✕ Ignoring class tests
Forgetting to check whether the plaintiff and the harm match the statute's protective purpose.
✕ Overlooking excuses
Treating every violation as automatic breach without screening for emergency or impossibility.

Quick Summary

Step Question If Yes
ViolationStatute broken?Proceed to tests
PersonsP in protected class?Continue
HarmInjury type prevented?Continue
ExcuseExcuse available?Per se defeated
CauseCaused damages?Liability

Question 1 of 5

Which two elements of negligence are typically established by a successful negligence per se claim?

Question 2 of 5

A statute requires railroad gates at crossings to prevent collisions with trains. A pedestrian trips over a broken gate arm and breaks an ankle. Does negligence per se likely apply?

Question 3 of 5

A driver fails to use headlights at night because they suddenly burned out without warning, despite a recent inspection. The best argument against negligence per se is:

Question 4 of 5

In a majority jurisdiction, what is the effect of an unexcused violation of an applicable safety statute?

Question 5 of 5

Which conclusion is most accurate?

You've Got Negligence Per Se

✓
Statute sets the standard: violation = duty + breach.
✓
Two tests: right class of persons AND right class of harm.
✓
Always screen excuses and remember to prove causation and damages.