Negligence
Per Se
When breaking a statute automatically establishes breach of duty: applying statutory rules in tort law.
What Is Negligence Per Se?
In an ordinary negligence claim, the plaintiff must prove that the defendant's conduct fell below a reasonable standard of care. Negligence per se is a doctrine that lets a plaintiff borrow a statute or regulation to define that standard.
Negligence Has Four Elements
Why It Matters
The Core Rule
A statutory violation establishes negligence per se only when both threshold tests are satisfied. Think of it as a conjunction:
The plaintiff must be in the class of persons the statute was designed to protect, and the injury must be of the type of harm the statute was designed to prevent.
The Two-Part Test
Per Se vs. Evidence of Negligence
Jurisdictions differ on the effect of a statutory violation. Know which approach the question follows.
| Negligence Per Se | Mere Evidence | |
|---|---|---|
| Effect of violation | Conclusive on duty + breach | One factor jury may weigh |
| Jury role | No breach question | Decides if reasonable |
| Majority view | Conclusive (rebuttable) | Minority approach |
How to Apply It
Recognized Excuses
Even a clear violation may be excused, defeating negligence per se. Common excuses include:
Example 1: The Speeding Driver
A driver speeds through a school zone (violating a 25 mph limit) and strikes a child crossing the street. Does negligence per se apply?
Example 2: Wrong Type of Harm
A statute requires shipowners to keep animals penned to prevent the spread of disease. A storm sweeps unpenned sheep overboard, drowning them. The owner sues the carrier.
Example 3: An Excused Violation
A statute requires headlights at night. A driver's lights suddenly fail without warning despite recent inspection, and a collision follows in the dark. Negligence per se?
Lesson: even when both threshold tests pass, always screen for a recognized excuse before concluding per se applies.
Common Mistakes
Quick Summary
| Step | Question | If Yes |
|---|---|---|
| Violation | Statute broken? | Proceed to tests |
| Persons | P in protected class? | Continue |
| Harm | Injury type prevented? | Continue |
| Excuse | Excuse available? | Per se defeated |
| Cause | Caused damages? | Liability |
Question 1 of 5
Which two elements of negligence are typically established by a successful negligence per se claim?
Question 2 of 5
A statute requires railroad gates at crossings to prevent collisions with trains. A pedestrian trips over a broken gate arm and breaks an ankle. Does negligence per se likely apply?
Question 3 of 5
A driver fails to use headlights at night because they suddenly burned out without warning, despite a recent inspection. The best argument against negligence per se is:
Question 4 of 5
In a majority jurisdiction, what is the effect of an unexcused violation of an applicable safety statute?
Question 5 of 5
A city ordinance requires landlords to install working smoke detectors in every apartment to protect tenants from fire-related injuries. A landlord fails to install a detector. A fire breaks out at night; a tenant, unwarned, suffers severe smoke inhalation. The tenant sues the landlord, and the jurisdiction follows the majority approach to statutory violations.
Which conclusion is most accurate?