Negligence
Framework
Master the four-element test: Duty, Breach, Causation, and Damages, the backbone of every tort claim on the bar.
What Is Negligence?
Negligence is the failure to exercise the level of care that a reasonably prudent person would use under similar circumstances, resulting in harm to another.
The Four Elements
Element 1: Duty
A defendant owes a duty of care to all foreseeable plaintiffs, those who could reasonably be harmed by the defendant's conduct.
Element 2: Breach & the Hand Formula
A defendant breaches when conduct falls below the reasonable standard. Judge Learned Hand formalized this as a cost-benefit test:
Element 3: Causation
Element 4: Damages
The plaintiff must prove actual harm, a legally recognized injury. Negligence is not actionable without compensable damages.
The Prima Facie Case
Key Distinction: Negligence vs Intentional Tort
| Negligence | Intentional Tort | |
|---|---|---|
| Mental State | Carelessness | Intent / purpose |
| Damages | Actual harm required | Nominal available |
| Standard | Reasonable person | Knowing or purposeful act |
| Defenses | Comparative fault | Consent, self-defense |
How to Apply the Framework
Example 1: The Wet Floor
A grocery store leaves a spill unmarked for an hour. A shopper slips and breaks her wrist. Walk the framework:
Example 2: The Hand Formula
A factory could install a guard rail for $500 \( (B) \). The probability of a fall is \( P = 0.1 \) and the expected loss is \( L = \$80{,}000 \). Was failing to install it a breach?
Example 3: Superseding Cause
A driver negligently leaves keys in an unlocked car. A thief steals it and intentionally runs over a pedestrian. Is the driver liable?
Common Mistakes
Framework Summary
| Element | Question to Ask |
|---|---|
| Duty | Was a duty of care owed? |
| Breach | Did conduct fall below the standard \( (B < P \times L) \)? |
| Causation | Actual and proximate cause? |
| Damages | Was there actual, cognizable harm? |
Question 1 of 5
Which of the following is NOT one of the four elements of negligence?
Question 2 of 5
Under the Hand formula, a defendant is negligent when:
Question 3 of 5
"But-for the defendant's conduct, the harm would not have occurred" describes:
Question 4 of 5
A homeowner negligently leaves a ladder leaning against the house overnight. During the night, an arsonist uses the ladder to climb up and set fire to the roof, severely burning a sleeping guest.
The homeowner's strongest argument against liability for the burns is:
Question 5 of 5
A plaintiff proves duty, breach, and causation but cannot show any measurable injury. The negligence claim: