01 / 20

Negligence
Framework

Master the four-element test: Duty, Breach, Causation, and Damages, the backbone of every tort claim on the bar.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Negligence?

Negligence is the failure to exercise the level of care that a reasonably prudent person would use under similar circumstances, resulting in harm to another.

The Four Elements

Duty Breach Causation Damages

Element 1: Duty

A defendant owes a duty of care to all foreseeable plaintiffs, those who could reasonably be harmed by the defendant's conduct.

Cardozo View
Duty is owed only to plaintiffs within the foreseeable "zone of danger." (Majority)
Andrews View
Duty is owed to everyone; foreseeability is a question of proximate cause. (Minority)

Element 2: Breach & the Hand Formula

A defendant breaches when conduct falls below the reasonable standard. Judge Learned Hand formalized this as a cost-benefit test:

Element 3: Causation

Actual Cause
"But-for" the defendant's conduct, the harm would not have occurred.
Proximate Cause
The harm was a foreseeable result, no superseding intervening cause cuts off liability.

Element 4: Damages

The plaintiff must prove actual harm, a legally recognized injury. Negligence is not actionable without compensable damages.

Compensatory
Medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, the core of recovery.
No Nominal
Unlike intentional torts, nominal damages are not available in negligence.

The Prima Facie Case

1
Duty. Defendant owed plaintiff a legal duty of care.
2
Breach. Defendant breached that duty by failing to meet the standard of care.
3
Causation. The breach was both the actual and proximate cause of harm.
4
Damages. Plaintiff suffered actual, legally cognizable harm.

Key Distinction: Negligence vs Intentional Tort

NegligenceIntentional Tort
Mental StateCarelessnessIntent / purpose
DamagesActual harm requiredNominal available
StandardReasonable personKnowing or purposeful act
DefensesComparative faultConsent, self-defense

How to Apply the Framework

1
Identify the duty. Who owed a duty to whom, and what standard of care applies?
2
Apply the standard. Use the Hand formula \( (B < P \times L) \) or relevant statutes to test breach.
3
Trace causation. Confirm but-for cause, then check for superseding intervening events.
4
Quantify damages. Establish actual, measurable injury and then evaluate defenses.

Example 1: The Wet Floor

A grocery store leaves a spill unmarked for an hour. A shopper slips and breaks her wrist. Walk the framework:

Example 2: The Hand Formula

A factory could install a guard rail for $500 \( (B) \). The probability of a fall is \( P = 0.1 \) and the expected loss is \( L = \$80{,}000 \). Was failing to install it a breach?

Example 3: Superseding Cause

A driver negligently leaves keys in an unlocked car. A thief steals it and intentionally runs over a pedestrian. Is the driver liable?

Common Mistakes

✕ Skipping Duty
Jumping to breach without first establishing that a duty was owed to this plaintiff.
✕ Conflating Causation
Treating actual and proximate cause as one. Both must be analyzed separately.
✕ Ignoring Damages
Forgetting that negligence requires actual harm, no nominal damages exist.

Framework Summary

ElementQuestion to Ask
DutyWas a duty of care owed?
BreachDid conduct fall below the standard \( (B < P \times L) \)?
CausationActual and proximate cause?
DamagesWas there actual, cognizable harm?

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following is NOT one of the four elements of negligence?

Question 2 of 5

Under the Hand formula, a defendant is negligent when:

Question 3 of 5

"But-for the defendant's conduct, the harm would not have occurred" describes:

Question 4 of 5

The homeowner's strongest argument against liability for the burns is:

Question 5 of 5

A plaintiff proves duty, breach, and causation but cannot show any measurable injury. The negligence claim: