Multi-Party
Liability
When more than one defendant causes a single harm, who pays and how much? Learn joint and several liability, contribution, and indemnity.
What Is Multi-Party Liability?
In many tort cases, more than one defendant contributes to a single, indivisible injury. The law must decide how the plaintiff's loss is allocated among them.
Three Core Doctrines
One Indivisible Injury
The Joint & Several Rule
If \( D_1 \) and \( D_2 \) are both liable for a $100,000 judgment, the plaintiff may collect: \( \$100{,}000 \) from \( D_1 \) alone, or \( \$100{,}000 \) from \( D_2 \) alone — but never more than $100,000 total.
When Joint Liability Applies
Contribution vs. Indemnity
| Contribution | Indemnity | |
|---|---|---|
| Recovers | Others' fair share | The entire loss |
| Among | Co-defendants at fault | Passively vs. actively liable |
| Effect | Splits the bill | Shifts the whole bill |
| Example | Two negligent drivers | Retailer sues manufacturer |
How Contribution Works
When one defendant pays more than their share of a joint judgment, they may sue co-defendants to recover the excess. Modern rule allocates by comparative fault.
A Step-by-Step Approach
Worked Example One
Drivers A and B negligently collide and injure pedestrian P. A judgment of \( \$200{,}000 \) is entered. A is 75% at fault, B is 25%. B is insolvent.
Worked Example Two
A retailer sells a defective product made by a manufacturer. A customer is injured and sues the retailer, who was not negligent and merely passed the product along sealed.
Worked Example Three
P is injured in a comparative-fault state and is found 20% at fault. Total damages are \( \$500{,}000 \). Defendants D1 (50%) and D2 (30%) are both solvent.
Common Mistakes
Quick Summary
| Concept | Who Sues Whom | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Joint & Several | Plaintiff → any defendant | Full judgment |
| Contribution | Defendant → co-defendants | Their fair shares |
| Indemnity | Passive D → active D | Entire loss |
| Divisible Harm | Plaintiff → each D | Only that D's portion |
Question 1 of 5
Under joint and several liability, how much may a plaintiff recover from a single defendant who is only 20% at fault for a $300,000 indivisible injury?
Question 2 of 5
A defendant who has paid more than their fair share of a joint judgment seeks to recover the excess from co-defendants. This remedy is called:
Question 3 of 5
A blameless retailer is held liable for selling a sealed defective product. To recover the full amount from the at-fault manufacturer, the retailer relies on:
Question 4 of 5
Drivers A (70%) and B (30%) cause a \( \$100{,}000 \) indivisible injury. B is insolvent. Who bears the risk of B's insolvency?
Question 5 of 5
When an injury is divisible — its causes can be clearly separated — how is each defendant's liability determined?