01 / 20

Motion to Dismiss
Rule 12 Standards

Learn how courts test a complaint under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12 and when a case gets thrown out before trial.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Motion to Dismiss?

A motion to dismiss is a defendant's early request asking the court to throw out a lawsuit before trial. It says: "Even taking everything the plaintiff claims as true, this case still cannot proceed."

Key Terms to Know

Complaint
The plaintiff's first filing that states the claims against the defendant.
Plaintiff
The party who files the lawsuit and seeks relief.
Defendant
The party being sued, who may move to dismiss.

Where It Fits in a Case

Complaint Plaintiff files Motion to Dismiss Rule 12 Discovery If it survives Trial

The Rule 12(b) Grounds

1
12(b)(1) — Lack of subject-matter jurisdiction.
2
12(b)(2) — Lack of personal jurisdiction.
3
12(b)(3) — Improper venue.
6
12(b)(6) — Failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted.

The 12(b)(6) Standard

Under Bell Atlantic v. Twombly and Ashcroft v. Iqbal, a complaint survives only if it pleads enough facts to make the claim plausible on its face.

The Plausibility Threshold

Sufficiency of facts Plausibility line Conclusory DISMISS Plausible SURVIVES Detailed SURVIVES

Dismiss vs. Summary Judgment

Motion to Dismiss Summary Judgment
Rule12(b)(6)56
TimingBefore answerAfter discovery
Looks atThe complaint onlyEvidence & affidavits
QuestionAre facts pleaded?Are facts disputed?

How to Apply the Test

1
Accept facts as true. Assume every factual allegation in the complaint is correct.
2
Ignore legal conclusions. Strip out bare conclusions like "defendant was negligent."
3
Test plausibility. Ask whether the remaining facts plausibly support each element.
4
Decide. If a claim is plausible, deny the motion. If not, grant dismissal.

Worked Example One

Complaint: "Defendant breached our contract and owes me money." No mention of any agreement, terms, or what the defendant failed to do.

Worked Example Two

Complaint: "On June 1, defendant signed a written lease to rent my warehouse for \( \$2{,}000 \) per month. Since March, defendant has paid nothing while still occupying the space."

Worked Example Three

Complaint: A negligence claim states the defendant "owed a duty, breached it, and caused harm" but adds that defendant "drove 25 mph over the limit through a red light and struck plaintiff's car."

Common Mistakes

✕ Weighing evidence
A 12(b)(6) motion never weighs proof — it only reads the complaint.
✕ Crediting conclusions
Bare legal labels do not count as facts and must be set aside.
✕ Demanding "probable"
The standard is plausibility, not probability or certainty.

Quick Summary

Survives Dismissed
Type of allegationConcrete factsLegal conclusions
PlausibilityAbove the lineBelow the line
Court's viewFacts accepted trueEven if true, no claim
Next stepDiscoveryCase ends

Question 1 of 5

When deciding a Rule 12(b)(6) motion, the court must treat the plaintiff's factual allegations as:

Question 2 of 5

Which ground is raised by a 12(b)(6) motion?

Question 3 of 5

How should the court most likely rule on a 12(b)(6) motion?

Question 4 of 5

The plausibility standard from Twombly and Iqbal requires facts that make a claim:

Question 5 of 5

What chiefly distinguishes a motion to dismiss from a motion for summary judgment?

You've Got the Standard

On the bar, watch for 12(b)(6) fact patterns and the keyword plausible. Apply the four-step chain every time and you'll spot the right answer fast.