The Mistake Doctrine
Mutual & Unilateral
When a contract is built on a false belief about a basic fact, the law may let a party escape the deal. Learn when a mistake makes a contract voidable.
What Counts as a Mistake?
In contract law, a mistake is a belief that is not in accord with the facts. It must be about a fact that exists at the time the contract is formed, not a prediction that later turns out wrong.
Two Kinds of Mistake
Visualizing the Difference
The Mutual Mistake Rule
A contract is voidable by the adversely affected party for mutual mistake when all three elements are met:
The Unilateral Mistake Rule
A one-sided mistake makes the contract voidable only if the three mutual-mistake elements are met and one of these added conditions exists:
Who Bears the Risk?
No relief is available if the complaining party bore the risk of the mistake. A party bears the risk when:
Mistake vs. Misunderstanding
Do not confuse a mistake (wrong belief about a fact) with a misunderstanding (the parties attach different meanings to a term).
How to Apply the Doctrine
Example 1: The Barren Cow
Sherwood v. Walker: A buyer and seller both believed the cow "Rose" was barren and priced her at $80 as beef. She was actually pregnant and worth roughly $750.
Example 2: The Bid Error
A contractor submits a bid of $50,000, but a clerical slip dropped a $30,000 line item. The true intended bid was $80,000. The owner sees the next-lowest bid was $79,000.
Example 3: The Risk Trap
A buyer purchases land "as is," hoping it contains oil. Both parties assume oil is present. It turns out there is none. The buyer sues to rescind.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Side-by-Side Summary
| Mutual | Unilateral | |
|---|---|---|
| Who is mistaken | Both parties | One party |
| Core 3-part test | Required | Required |
| Extra requirement | None | Unconscionable OR other party knew |
| Ease of rescission | Easier | Harder |
| Result if proven | Voidable | Voidable |
Question 1 of 5
A contract is "voidable" for mistake. What does that mean?
Question 2 of 5
Both a buyer and seller believe an antique vase is a genuine Ming dynasty piece worth a fortune. It is a modern reproduction. This is best classified as:
Question 3 of 5
For a unilateral mistake to make a contract voidable, what extra element is needed beyond the core three-part test?
Question 4 of 5
A wholesaler buys a parcel of farmland "as is," speculating that buried minerals might lie beneath. The seller also assumes minerals are present. After purchase, geological testing reveals no minerals at all.
The wholesaler sues to rescind, arguing both parties were mistaken about the presence of minerals.
Will the wholesaler likely succeed in rescinding?
Question 5 of 5
Two parties agree to deliver cotton on the ship "Peerless," but each means a different ship by that name, and both meanings are equally reasonable. The correct analysis is: