Misrepresentation
& Nondisclosure
When a deal is built on a false statement or hidden truth, the law may unwind it. Learn to evaluate fraud, materiality, and the duty to speak.
What Is a Misrepresentation?
A misrepresentation is an assertion that is not in accord with the facts. In contract law, it can make an agreement voidable by the party who was misled into entering the deal.
Three Flavors of Misrepresentation
The Materiality Threshold
A misrepresentation is material if it would likely induce a reasonable person to agree, or if the maker knows it would induce this particular person to agree.
The Core Rule: Elements of Fraud
The Heart of Fraud: Scienter
Scienter means the maker had a guilty mind about the statement's truth. It is satisfied when the speaker:
When Silence Becomes a Lie
The general rule is caveat emptor: no duty to volunteer facts. But nondisclosure is treated as a misrepresentation in four specific situations.
Four Duties to Disclose
Fact vs. Opinion & Puffery
How to Attack a Fact Pattern
Worked Example: The Odometer
A seller tells a buyer the used car has 40,000 miles. The seller knows it actually has 120,000 miles. The buyer pays and later discovers the truth.
Worked Example: The Half-Truth
A homeowner tells a buyer the roof "was fully replaced last year" but omits that the new roof leaks badly in every rainstorm: a fact she knows.
Worked Example: Innocent Error
A seller reasonably believes a painting is an authentic original and says so. Both parties later learn it is a skilled forgery. The seller had no reason to doubt it.
Common Mistakes
Summary Comparison
| Fraudulent | Negligent | Innocent | |
|---|---|---|---|
| State of mind | Knew / reckless | Careless | Honest belief |
| Materiality required? | No | Yes | Yes |
| Rescission | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Tort damages | Yes | Sometimes | No |
Question 1 of 5
Which element distinguishes a fraudulent misrepresentation from a negligent one?
Question 2 of 5
A seller paints over a large crack in a foundation wall before showing a house. This is best described as:
Question 3 of 5
Which statement about materiality is correct?
Question 4 of 5
A car dealer tells a buyer, "This vehicle has never been in an accident." At the time, the dealer honestly believes this. The next day, before the sale closes, a mechanic informs the dealer that the car was, in fact, in a major collision. The dealer says nothing and completes the sale.
What duty does the dealer's new knowledge trigger?
Question 5 of 5
A seller innocently and reasonably misstates a material fact that induces the buyer to contract. Which remedy is available?