Misrepresentation
in Contract Law
When a contract is built on a false statement of fact, the deceived party may avoid the deal. Learn to apply the misrepresentation doctrines tested on the bar.
What Is a Misrepresentation?
A misrepresentation is an assertion not in accord with the facts. When one party induces another to enter a contract by making a false statement, the agreement may be voidable by the misled party.
The Five Elements
From False Statement to Rescission
The Core Rule
A statement that is fraudulent need not be material. A statement that is material need not be fraudulent. Either one, plus justifiable reliance, is enough to make the contract voidable.
Fraudulent vs. Material
When Does Silence Count?
The default rule: silence is not a misrepresentation. But concealment or nondisclosure becomes actionable in specific situations.
How to Apply the Doctrine
Worked Example One
A car dealer tells a buyer the used car "has never been in an accident." It was in a major collision. The buyer relies and purchases.
Worked Example Two
A seller of a house says, "This is the finest neighborhood in town." The buyer later disagrees and wants to rescind.
Worked Example Three
A homeowner painting over a wall to hide visible water damage sells the home. The buyer cannot see the defect and buys.
Common Mistakes
Summary Comparison
| Fraudulent | Material | Innocent | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scienter | Yes | No | No |
| Materiality | Not required | Yes | Required |
| Rescission | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Tort damages | ✓ | Limited | ✕ |
Test Your Understanding
Five questions ahead. Apply the misrepresentation doctrines: identify the assertion, the path (fraud or materiality), reliance, and the correct remedy.
Question 1 of 5
A misrepresentation generally makes the resulting contract:
Question 2 of 5
A statement that is fraudulent but not material can still make a contract voidable. True path?
Question 3 of 5
A seller says a painting is "a masterpiece worth millions." It is mediocre. The buyer relies and overpays. Best characterization?
Question 4 of 5
When can mere silence amount to an actionable misrepresentation?
Question 5 of 5
Facts: A homeowner negligently states the roof is "only three years old," genuinely believing it but mistaken — the roof is fifteen years old and the misstatement is significant to any buyer. The buyer reasonably relies and purchases.
The homeowner had no intent to deceive and no knowledge of falsity, but the statement was significant to the transaction.
Which remedy is most clearly available to the buyer?