01 / 20

Miranda
Application

Learn exactly when Miranda warnings are required: the two-part trigger of custody and interrogation.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is the Miranda Rule?

From Miranda v. Arizona (1966), the rule protects the Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination. Before police may use statements from a suspect, they must give warnings.

Why It Matters

If Miranda applies but warnings are not given, any statement obtained is presumptively inadmissible in the prosecution's case-in-chief.

The Two-Part Trigger

CUSTODY freedom restrained INTERROGATION questioning by police + MIRANDA APPLIES warnings required

Defining Custody

Custody exists when a reasonable person in the suspect's position would not feel free to leave or terminate the encounter, akin to a formal arrest.

Likely Custody
Formal arrest, handcuffs, locked interrogation room, prolonged station detention.
Likely Not Custody
Routine traffic stop, brief Terry stop, voluntary visit to the station, ordinary questioning at home.

Defining Interrogation

Interrogation is express questioning or its functional equivalent: words or conduct police should know are reasonably likely to elicit an incriminating response (Rhode Island v. Innis).

The Core Rule

1
Custody present? Reasonable person not free to leave.
2
Interrogation present? Questioning or its functional equivalent.
3
Both yes? Miranda applies. Otherwise, it does not.

A Key Exception

Even when both prongs are met, the public safety exception (New York v. Quarles) allows unwarned questioning when there is an immediate threat to public safety, such as asking where a discarded gun is.

Miranda vs. 6th Amendment Right to Counsel

Miranda (5th Am.) 6th Am. Counsel
When it attachesCustodial interrogationFormal charges filed
Offense scopeAny crimeOffense-specific
TriggerCustody + interrogationAdversarial proceedings begin

How to Apply It

1
Ask: custody? Would a reasonable person feel free to leave?
2
Ask: interrogation? Express questions or conduct likely to elicit a response?
3
Both met? Warnings required. If not, no Miranda.
4
Check exceptions. Public safety, routine booking, spontaneous statements.

Worked Example 1

An officer makes a routine traffic stop and asks the driver, "Do you know how fast you were going?" The driver admits to speeding.

Worked Example 2

A suspect is arrested, handcuffed, and placed in a locked patrol car. Without prompting, he blurts out, "I did it, I robbed the store."

Worked Example 3

A suspect is arrested and taken to a locked interrogation room at the station. Officers question him about a murder without giving any warnings.

Common Mistakes

✕ Arrest = Miranda
Arrest alone is not enough. You still need interrogation for Miranda to apply.
✕ Questioning = Miranda
Questioning without custody (e.g., a traffic stop) does not trigger Miranda.
✕ Ignoring spontaneity
Volunteered statements are not interrogation and are admissible.
✕ Confusing 5th and 6th
Miranda is Fifth Amendment based, not the offense-specific Sixth Amendment right.

Quick Reference

Custody Interrogation Result
YesYesApply (warnings needed)
YesNoNo Miranda
NoYesNo Miranda
NoNoNo Miranda

Question 1 of 5

Miranda warnings are required only when there is custody and what other element?

Question 2 of 5

During a routine traffic stop, an officer asks the driver if he had been drinking. Is the driver in "custody" for Miranda purposes?

Question 3 of 5

A handcuffed, arrested suspect spontaneously blurts out a confession without any police questioning. Is the statement barred by Miranda?

Question 4 of 5

Under which doctrine may police ask an unwarned question (like "Where is the gun?") and still use the answer?

Question 5 of 5

What is the likely admissibility of the confession in the prosecution's case-in-chief?