01 / 20

LLC Governance
Management Structures

Learn how a limited liability company is run, who has authority to act, and how to spot a member-managed versus manager-managed structure on the bar exam.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is an LLC?

A limited liability company (LLC) is a business entity that blends the limited liability of a corporation with the pass-through taxation and flexibility of a partnership. Its owners are called members.

Key Terms

Member
An owner of the LLC who holds a membership interest.
Manager
A person (member or non-member) designated to run the business.
Operating Agreement
The contract among members governing internal affairs.

Two Governance Structures

Member-Managed The Business Member A Member B All members run the company Manager-Managed The Business Manager Member Member Members appoint the manager

The Default Rule

Stated formally: let \( M \) be the management mode. Then the default is \( M = \text{member-managed} \), and \( M = \text{manager-managed} \) only when the operating agreement so provides.

Member-Managed: Authority

1
Equal rights. Each member has equal rights in management, regardless of capital contributed.
2
Agency authority. Each member is an agent who can bind the LLC in the ordinary course of business.
3
Ordinary decisions. Decided by a majority of the members.

Manager-Managed: Authority

1
Managers control. Only managers have authority to bind the LLC in the ordinary course of business.
2
Members lose agency. A non-manager member is not an agent and cannot bind the LLC simply by being a member.
3
Members retain a voice. Members still vote on extraordinary matters (e.g., amending the operating agreement, admitting members).

Key Distinction: Who Can Bind?

Member-Managed Manager-Managed
Who runs daily opsAll membersManager(s)
Member as agentYesNo
Manager as agentN/AYes
Ordinary decisionsMajority of membersManager(s)
Default under RULLCAYesNo

Extraordinary Matters Need All Members

Some decisions are so fundamental that they require the consent of all members in both structures, regardless of who manages:

Amend Agreement
Changing the operating agreement.
Admit Members
Adding a new member to the LLC.
Sell All Assets
Selling substantially all the LLC's property outside the ordinary course.

How to Analyze a Fact Pattern

1
Check the operating agreement. Does it expressly elect manager-management? If silent, apply the member-managed default.
2
Identify the actor. Is the person a member, a manager, or both?
3
Classify the act. Ordinary course or extraordinary matter?
4
Conclude. Did the actor have authority to bind the LLC?

Worked Example 1

Facts: Ana, Ben, and Cara form an LLC. Their operating agreement is silent on management. Ana signs a contract to buy office supplies for the business. Is the LLC bound?

Worked Example 2

Facts: An LLC's agreement expressly elects manager-management and names Dev as manager. Member Ed (not a manager) signs a lease for the business. Is the LLC bound?

Worked Example 3

Facts: A member-managed LLC has 4 members. Manager Faye (a member) wants to sell substantially all the LLC's assets. Two of four members object. May the sale proceed?

Common Mistakes

✕ Wrong default
Assuming manager-management is the default. Silence means member-managed under RULLCA.
✕ Members always bind
Forgetting that in a manager-managed LLC, ordinary members are not agents.
✕ Capital = control
Thinking a bigger contribution means more management votes. Default is equal rights.

Quick Summary

IssueRule
Default managementMember-managed
Voting (ordinary)Majority of members
Voting (extraordinary)Unanimous consent
Who binds (member-mgd)Any member
Who binds (manager-mgd)Manager only

Question 1 of 5

An LLC's operating agreement says nothing about how it will be managed. Under RULLCA, what is the management structure?

Question 2 of 5

In a manager-managed LLC, a member who is not a manager signs an ordinary-course contract. Absent apparent authority, is the LLC bound?

Question 3 of 5

In a member-managed LLC, how are ordinary business decisions made by default?

Question 4 of 5

Which decision typically requires the consent of all members regardless of the management structure?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement best describes their management rights?