01 / 20

Liability
Apportionment

How to allocate damages among multiple defendants when several parties share fault for a single injury.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

The Core Problem

When two or more defendants contribute to a single, indivisible injury, the court must decide who pays what. This is the work of liability apportionment.

Three Key Terms

Joint & Several Liability
Each defendant can be liable for the full amount of damages, regardless of their share of fault.
Several (Proportionate) Liability
Each defendant pays only their own percentage of fault.
Contribution
A defendant who overpays can recover the excess from co-defendants.

One Injury, Many Defendants

Plaintiff
\(\$100{,}000\) injury
Defendant A
\(60\%\) fault
Defendant B
\(30\%\) fault
Defendant C
\(10\%\) fault

Rule: Joint & Several Liability

The plaintiff is guaranteed full recovery: $$\text{Recovery from any single D} = \text{Total Damages}$$

A defendant who pays more than their share then seeks contribution to balance the loss.

Rule: Several Liability

Each defendant's obligation is: $$D_i = \text{Total Damages} \times \frac{\text{Fault}_i}{100\%}$$

If Defendant A is \(60\%\) at fault on a $100{,}000 claim, A owes exactly $$0.60 \times \$100{,}000 = \$60{,}000.$$

Who Bears the Insolvency Risk?

Joint & Several Several Only
Plaintiff may collect full amount from one DYesNo
Each D pays only their fault shareNoYes
Risk of insolvent defendant falls onDefendantsPlaintiff
Contribution availableYesGenerally N/A

Contribution vs. Indemnity

Contribution
Splits the loss proportionally. A defendant who pays more than their share recovers the excess from co-defendants based on relative fault.
Indemnity
Shifts the entire loss to another party. Available where one party is only passively/vicariously liable for another's active fault.

A Step-by-Step Approach

1
Identify all tortfeasors who contributed to the indivisible injury.
2
Assign percentages of fault to each defendant (and to the plaintiff, if comparative fault applies).
3
Determine the rule in force: joint & several, several only, or a hybrid.
4
Calculate each share using \( D_i = \text{Damages} \times \text{Fault}_i \).
5
Resolve insolvency and apply contribution/indemnity to reallocate.

Reduce for the Plaintiff's Fault

If the plaintiff is partly to blame, damages are reduced before apportioning among defendants under comparative fault:

$$\text{Recoverable} = \text{Total Damages} \times (1 - \text{Plaintiff Fault})$$

Worked Example 1

A jury awards $200,000. Fault: \(D_1\) = \(50\%\), \(D_2\) = \(30\%\), \(D_3\) = \(20\%\). Rule: several liability only.

Under several liability, the plaintiff collects each amount separately. No defendant covers another's share.

Worked Example 2: Insolvency

Same $200,000 award and fault shares, but rule is joint & several — and \(D_2\) is insolvent.

\(D_2\)'s \(\$60,000\) share is split between \(D_1\) and \(D_3\) in a \(50:20\) ratio. \(D_1\) absorbs \( \$60{,}000 \times \frac{50}{70} \approx \$42{,}857 \), and \(D_3\) absorbs the rest.

Worked Example 3: Plaintiff Fault

Damages = $100,000. Plaintiff is \(25\%\) at fault. \(D_1\) = \(45\%\), \(D_2\) = \(30\%\). Rule: several liability.

\(D_1\) owes \( 0.60 \times \$75{,}000 = \) $45,000; \(D_2\) owes \( 0.40 \times \$75{,}000 = \) $30,000.

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing the Two Rules
Applying several-only math when the jurisdiction uses joint & several (or vice versa).
✕ Skipping Plaintiff Reduction
Apportioning the full award without first reducing for the plaintiff's own fault.
✕ Contribution = Indemnity
Treating partial reimbursement (contribution) as full loss-shifting (indemnity).
✕ Ignoring Insolvency
Forgetting to reallocate an insolvent defendant's share among solvent ones.

Summary Cheat Sheet

Concept What It Does Key Formula / Trigger
Joint & SeveralAny D liable for full amount\( \text{Recovery} = \text{Total Damages} \)
SeveralEach D pays own share\( D_i = \text{Damages} \times \text{Fault}_i \)
Comparative FaultReduce for plaintiff fault\( \times (1 - \text{P Fault}) \)
ContributionRecover overpaid excessBy relative fault
IndemnityShift entire lossPassive/vicarious liability

Question 1 of 5

Under joint and several liability, from whom may the plaintiff collect the full judgment?

Question 2 of 5

Damages are $300,000. A defendant is \(40\%\) at fault under several liability only. How much does this defendant owe?

Question 3 of 5

In a pure several liability system, who bears the risk that a defendant is insolvent?

Question 4 of 5

A plaintiff suffers $100,000 in damages but is \(20\%\) at fault under comparative fault. What amount may be apportioned among the defendants?

Question 5 of 5

A defendant who pays more than their fault share and seeks partial reimbursement from co-defendants is exercising a right of: