Liability
Apportionment
How to allocate damages among multiple defendants when several parties share fault for a single injury.
The Core Problem
When two or more defendants contribute to a single, indivisible injury, the court must decide who pays what. This is the work of liability apportionment.
Three Key Terms
One Injury, Many Defendants
Rule: Joint & Several Liability
The plaintiff is guaranteed full recovery: $$\text{Recovery from any single D} = \text{Total Damages}$$
A defendant who pays more than their share then seeks contribution to balance the loss.
Rule: Several Liability
Each defendant's obligation is: $$D_i = \text{Total Damages} \times \frac{\text{Fault}_i}{100\%}$$
If Defendant A is \(60\%\) at fault on a $100{,}000 claim, A owes exactly $$0.60 \times \$100{,}000 = \$60{,}000.$$
Who Bears the Insolvency Risk?
| Joint & Several | Several Only | |
|---|---|---|
| Plaintiff may collect full amount from one D | Yes | No |
| Each D pays only their fault share | No | Yes |
| Risk of insolvent defendant falls on | Defendants | Plaintiff |
| Contribution available | Yes | Generally N/A |
Contribution vs. Indemnity
A Step-by-Step Approach
Reduce for the Plaintiff's Fault
If the plaintiff is partly to blame, damages are reduced before apportioning among defendants under comparative fault:
$$\text{Recoverable} = \text{Total Damages} \times (1 - \text{Plaintiff Fault})$$
Worked Example 1
A jury awards $200,000. Fault: \(D_1\) = \(50\%\), \(D_2\) = \(30\%\), \(D_3\) = \(20\%\). Rule: several liability only.
Under several liability, the plaintiff collects each amount separately. No defendant covers another's share.
Worked Example 2: Insolvency
Same $200,000 award and fault shares, but rule is joint & several — and \(D_2\) is insolvent.
\(D_2\)'s \(\$60,000\) share is split between \(D_1\) and \(D_3\) in a \(50:20\) ratio. \(D_1\) absorbs \( \$60{,}000 \times \frac{50}{70} \approx \$42{,}857 \), and \(D_3\) absorbs the rest.
Worked Example 3: Plaintiff Fault
Damages = $100,000. Plaintiff is \(25\%\) at fault. \(D_1\) = \(45\%\), \(D_2\) = \(30\%\). Rule: several liability.
\(D_1\) owes \( 0.60 \times \$75{,}000 = \) $45,000; \(D_2\) owes \( 0.40 \times \$75{,}000 = \) $30,000.
Common Mistakes
Summary Cheat Sheet
| Concept | What It Does | Key Formula / Trigger |
|---|---|---|
| Joint & Several | Any D liable for full amount | \( \text{Recovery} = \text{Total Damages} \) |
| Several | Each D pays own share | \( D_i = \text{Damages} \times \text{Fault}_i \) |
| Comparative Fault | Reduce for plaintiff fault | \( \times (1 - \text{P Fault}) \) |
| Contribution | Recover overpaid excess | By relative fault |
| Indemnity | Shift entire loss | Passive/vicarious liability |
Question 1 of 5
Under joint and several liability, from whom may the plaintiff collect the full judgment?
Question 2 of 5
Damages are $300,000. A defendant is \(40\%\) at fault under several liability only. How much does this defendant owe?
Question 3 of 5
In a pure several liability system, who bears the risk that a defendant is insolvent?
Question 4 of 5
A plaintiff suffers $100,000 in damages but is \(20\%\) at fault under comparative fault. What amount may be apportioned among the defendants?
Question 5 of 5
A defendant who pays more than their fault share and seeks partial reimbursement from co-defendants is exercising a right of: