Legal Analysis
Drafting
Draft sections of memos, briefs, and letters using original legal analysis built on a clear, structured framework.
What Is Legal Analysis?
Legal analysis is the process of applying law to facts to reach a reasoned conclusion. Drafting that analysis means putting your reasoning into writing in a way a busy reader can follow and trust.
Key Terms
Where Analysis Appears
The same analytical engine powers different documents, but tone and audience shift:
The Core Framework: IRAC
The Application Is the Heart
Most weak drafts state the rule, then jump to a conclusion. The grading credit lives in the application: explicitly tying each fact to each element of the rule.
Objective vs. Persuasive
| Objective (Memo) | Persuasive (Brief) | |
|---|---|---|
| Goal | Predict outcome | Win for client |
| Tone | Neutral, balanced | Advocacy, framed |
| Weak facts | Acknowledge openly | Address, minimize |
| Audience | Supervising attorney | Judge or panel |
A Step-by-Step Approach
Worked Example: Negligence Memo
Facts: A store left a wet floor unmarked for 30 minutes; a customer slipped and broke a wrist. Does the store breach its duty of care?
Stronger Example: Counterargument
A complete application weighs both sides. Notice how the application here does not just favor the client.
The phrase "On balance" signals a reasoned weighing, the mark of original analysis rather than rule recitation.
Persuasive Reframe: Brief
Take the same facts to a brief. The objective memo predicts; the brief advocates.
Common Mistakes
Quick Summary
| Step | Ask Yourself | Watch For |
|---|---|---|
| Issue | What is the question? | Too broad or vague |
| Rule | What law controls? | Missing citation |
| Application | How do facts meet law? | Too thin |
| Conclusion | What is the answer? | Unsupported |
Question 1 of 5
In the IRAC framework, which component does the bar examiners typically reward most?
Question 2 of 5
You are asked to draft an objective memo to a supervising attorney. How should you handle facts that hurt your client?
Question 3 of 5
Draft excerpt: "Under the controlling statute, a contract requires offer, acceptance, and consideration. The plaintiff and defendant had a contract. Therefore, the defendant must perform."
The drafter then submits this as the full analysis section.
What is the primary weakness of this draft?
Question 4 of 5
A phrase like "On balance, the stronger argument is..." in a draft signals what?
Question 5 of 5
When converting an objective memo's analysis into a persuasive brief, what primarily changes?