Lay Opinion
Testimony
Learn when an ordinary witness may offer an opinion under FRE 701 and how to evaluate it on the bar exam.
What Is a Lay Opinion?
A lay witness is an ordinary, non-expert witness. The general rule is that witnesses testify only to facts they perceived, not their conclusions or opinions.
The bar exam tests whether you can recognize when a lay opinion is admissible and when it crosses into territory reserved for expert witnesses under FRE 702.
Two Kinds of Witnesses
The FRE 701 Three-Part Test
A lay witness opinion is admissible only if it satisfies all three requirements:
Requirement 1: Personal Perception
The witness must have personally observed the matter through their senses: seeing, hearing, smelling, touching, or tasting.
Requirements 2 & 3: Helpful & Non-Expert
Classic Permissible Lay Opinions
Courts routinely allow lay opinions on everyday matters within common experience:
Key Distinction: Lay vs. Expert
How to Analyze a Lay Opinion
Worked Example: The Drunk Driver
Worked Example: The Medical Diagnosis
Worked Example: The Familiar Voice
Voice identification by someone familiar with the speaker is a classic lay opinion. The familiarity supplies the perception, the ID is helpful, and recognizing a known voice is within common experience.
Common Mistakes
Summary: Lay vs. Expert Opinion
| Lay Opinion (701) | Expert Opinion (702) | |
|---|---|---|
| Witness type | Ordinary person | Qualified expert |
| Basis | Personal perception | Specialized knowledge |
| Must be helpful? | Yes | Yes |
| Example | "He seemed drunk." | "BAC was 0.15%." |
| Qualification needed? | No | Yes |
Question 1 of 5
Which of the following is required for a lay witness to give an opinion under FRE 701?
Question 2 of 5
A witness who saw an accident testifies, "The defendant's car was going at least 70 mph." This is most likely:
Question 3 of 5
A bystander testifies that the injured plaintiff "suffered a torn rotator cuff." The opinion is most likely:
Question 4 of 5
A witness who has known her brother for 30 years hears a recording and says, "That's my brother's voice." Why is this admissible?
Question 5 of 5
Which statement best captures the dividing line between lay and expert opinion?