Justification
Defenses
When conduct that would otherwise be a crime is legally permitted. Master self-defense, defense of others, and the rules of force and proportionality.
What Is a Justification?
A justification defense says the defendant's conduct was not wrongful at all. Society deems the act socially acceptable or even desirable under the circumstances. The act is still committed, but it is not condemned.
The Family of Justifications
Why It Matters
The Self-Defense Rule
A person may use reasonable force to defend against an imminent unlawful threat of harm. The key is whether the defendant's belief in the need for force was honest and reasonable.
Deadly vs. Non-Deadly Force
Aggressors & the Duty to Retreat
Defending Others & Property
Necessity: The Choice of Evils
Necessity permits otherwise-criminal conduct when reasonably needed to avoid a greater imminent harm caused by natural forces. The defendant must not have created the situation.
How to Analyze a Fact Pattern
Worked Example: Bar Fight
Facts: Dan is shoved hard by Vic in a bar. Vic raises a fist to swing again. Dan punches Vic once to stop him. Vic falls and is unhurt. Dan is charged with battery.
Worked Example: Excessive Force
Facts: Vic slaps Dan once and turns to walk away. Dan, enraged, draws a knife and stabs Vic, who dies. Dan claims self-defense.
Worked Example: Defense of Others
Facts: Dan sees Stranger pinned and being beaten with a tire iron. Dan tackles the attacker, breaking the attacker's arm. The attacker was actually a plainclothes officer making a lawful arrest of a violent suspect.
Common Mistakes
Summary Comparison
| Triggering Threat | Deadly Force? | |
|---|---|---|
| Self-Defense | Imminent unlawful harm | Yes if threat is deadly |
| Defense of Others | Threat to third person | Yes if they could |
| Defense of Property | Threat to property | Never |
| Necessity | Greater natural harm | No (no killing) |
Question 1 of 5
What is the most fundamental difference between a justification and an excuse?
Question 2 of 5
Dan, pinned to the ground, is being strangled by Vic. Dan grabs a rock and strikes Vic, killing him. Is Dan justified?
Question 3 of 5
A homeowner sets a hidden spring-gun to kill any intruder who enters an empty cabin to steal tools. An unarmed burglar enters and is killed. Most likely result?
Question 4 of 5
Dan genuinely but unreasonably believed Vic was about to shoot him, so Dan shot Vic first. Vic was actually holding a phone. What is the likely outcome?
Question 5 of 5
Facts: Dan starts a fistfight by shoving Vic. Vic responds by pulling a knife and lunging to stab Dan. Dan, now facing a deadly threat, picks up a bottle and strikes Vic, knocking him out. Dan is charged with battery and raises self-defense.
Can Dan, the initial aggressor, claim self-defense?