01 / 20

Justification
Defenses

When conduct that would otherwise be a crime is legally permitted. Master self-defense, defense of others, and the rules of force and proportionality.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Justification?

A justification defense says the defendant's conduct was not wrongful at all. Society deems the act socially acceptable or even desirable under the circumstances. The act is still committed, but it is not condemned.

The Family of Justifications

Justification Self-Defense protect self Defense of others Defense of property Necessity choice of evils Each requires a threat that is imminent, and a response that is proportional

Why It Matters

Complete Defense
A valid justification results in full acquittal, not just mitigation.
Affirmative
The defendant usually bears the burden of producing evidence to raise it.
Heavily Tested
Self-defense fact patterns appear on nearly every bar exam.

The Self-Defense Rule

A person may use reasonable force to defend against an imminent unlawful threat of harm. The key is whether the defendant's belief in the need for force was honest and reasonable.

1
Imminent threat. The harm must be about to occur, not past or speculative.
2
Unlawful force. The threat must come from an aggressor acting wrongfully.
3
Proportional response. Force used must match the level of threat faced.
4
Reasonable belief. Judged by what a reasonable person would perceive.

Deadly vs. Non-Deadly Force

Non-Deadly Force Allowed when you reasonably believe force is needed to prevent imminent unlawful harm. No duty to retreat (majority rule) Deadly Force Allowed ONLY against a threat of death or serious bodily injury (or violent felony). Minority: must retreat if safely possible (except in own home)

Aggressors & the Duty to Retreat

1
Initial aggressor. One who starts the conflict generally cannot claim self-defense.
2
Regaining the right. An aggressor may regain it by withdrawing and clearly communicating that withdrawal.
3
Escalation exception. If the victim suddenly escalates to deadly force, the original aggressor may defend.
4
Castle doctrine. No duty to retreat from one's own home, even in retreat jurisdictions.

Defending Others & Property

Defense of Others
You may use force to defend a third person who would themselves be entitled to self-defense. Majority rule judges by reasonable appearances.
Defense of Property
Reasonable non-deadly force may protect property. Deadly force is never allowed solely to defend property.

Necessity: The Choice of Evils

Necessity permits otherwise-criminal conduct when reasonably needed to avoid a greater imminent harm caused by natural forces. The defendant must not have created the situation.

How to Analyze a Fact Pattern

1
Identify the threat. Is it imminent? Unlawful? From whom?
2
Classify the force used. Deadly or non-deadly?
3
Check proportionality. Does the response match the threat?
4
Apply special rules. Aggressor status, retreat, castle doctrine.
5
Test reasonableness. Was the defendant's belief honest AND objectively reasonable?

Worked Example: Bar Fight

Facts: Dan is shoved hard by Vic in a bar. Vic raises a fist to swing again. Dan punches Vic once to stop him. Vic falls and is unhurt. Dan is charged with battery.

Worked Example: Excessive Force

Facts: Vic slaps Dan once and turns to walk away. Dan, enraged, draws a knife and stabs Vic, who dies. Dan claims self-defense.

Worked Example: Defense of Others

Facts: Dan sees Stranger pinned and being beaten with a tire iron. Dan tackles the attacker, breaking the attacker's arm. The attacker was actually a plainclothes officer making a lawful arrest of a violent suspect.

Common Mistakes

✕ Ignoring Imminence
Self-defense never justifies retaliation for a past harm or a future threat. The danger must be happening now.
✕ Deadly for Property
Deadly force is never permitted to protect property alone. Remembering this catches many fact patterns.
✕ Forgetting Aggressor
The initial aggressor generally loses the defense unless they withdraw or the victim escalates.
✕ Subjective Only
A genuine but unreasonable belief is "imperfect self-defense" — it may reduce murder to manslaughter, not acquit.

Summary Comparison

Triggering Threat Deadly Force?
Self-DefenseImminent unlawful harmYes if threat is deadly
Defense of OthersThreat to third personYes if they could
Defense of PropertyThreat to propertyNever
NecessityGreater natural harmNo (no killing)

Question 1 of 5

What is the most fundamental difference between a justification and an excuse?

Question 2 of 5

Dan, pinned to the ground, is being strangled by Vic. Dan grabs a rock and strikes Vic, killing him. Is Dan justified?

Question 3 of 5

A homeowner sets a hidden spring-gun to kill any intruder who enters an empty cabin to steal tools. An unarmed burglar enters and is killed. Most likely result?

Question 4 of 5

Dan genuinely but unreasonably believed Vic was about to shoot him, so Dan shot Vic first. Vic was actually holding a phone. What is the likely outcome?

Question 5 of 5

Can Dan, the initial aggressor, claim self-defense?