01 / 20

Joinder of Claims
& Parties

How federal courts let litigants bundle multiple claims and parties into a single lawsuit under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Joinder?

Joinder is the procedural mechanism that determines which claims and which parties can be combined in one civil action. Instead of filing many separate lawsuits, the rules let related disputes be resolved together for efficiency and to avoid inconsistent judgments.

The Big Picture

Joinder Joinder of Claims Joinder of Parties Rule 18(a) Counterclaims 13 Permissive 20 / Compulsory 19

Core Rule: Rule 18(a)

Rule 18 is permissive and extremely broad. Once you have a proper claim against a party, you may pile on any other claim you hold against that same party. There is no transactional relationship requirement for joining claims under Rule 18.

Rule 18 in Action

Plaintiff (P) Defendant (D) Claim 1: Breach of contract Claim 2: Unrelated car accident Claim 3: Defamation

Permissive Party Joinder: Rule 20

Unlike claims, joining parties requires a connection. Under Rule 20, plaintiffs may join together (and defendants may be joined) only when two conditions are met:

1
Same transaction or occurrence: the claims arise out of the same transaction, occurrence, or series of transactions.
2
Common question: there is a question of law or fact common to all the parties being joined.

Compulsory Party Joinder: Rule 19

Some absentees are so important the court must consider whether to add them. A "required party" under Rule 19 is one where:

1
Complete relief cannot be granted among existing parties without them; or
2
The absentee claims an interest that would be impaired, or that would expose a party to multiple/inconsistent obligations.
3
If a required party cannot be joined, the court decides whether to proceed or dismiss (Rule 19(b) "indispensable" analysis).

Key Distinction: Claims vs. Parties

Joining Claims (Rule 18)
No relatedness needed. Any claim against an opposing party may be joined. Permissive.
Joining Parties (Rule 20)
Requires same transaction/occurrence AND a common question of law or fact.
Required Parties (Rule 19)
Court must consider; some absentees are "indispensable" and force dismissal if unjoinable.

Rule 13: Counter & Crossclaims

Compulsory Counterclaim
Arises from the same transaction/occurrence as the opposing claim. Must be raised or it's waived.
Permissive Counterclaim
Any claim not arising from the same transaction. May be raised but isn't required.
Crossclaim (13(g))
Against a co-party; must arise from the same transaction/occurrence. Always permissive.

How to Analyze a Joinder Problem

1
Identify the move: Is someone joining a claim or a party? Plaintiff, defendant, or absentee?
2
Pick the rule: Claims → Rule 18 / 13; Parties → Rule 20 (permissive) or Rule 19 (required).
3
Apply the test: Check transaction/occurrence and common-question prongs where required.
4
Check jurisdiction: Joinder ≠ jurisdiction. Confirm subject-matter (and supplemental) jurisdiction separately.

Worked Example 1

Facts: P sues D for breach of a January contract. P also wants to add a wholly unrelated claim that D rear-ended P's car in March. Can P join the car-accident claim?

Worked Example 2

Facts: Three passengers injured in the same bus crash want to sue the bus company together in one lawsuit. May they join as co-plaintiffs?

P1 P2 P3 Bus Co. (D) Same crash · common questions

Worked Example 3

Facts: Two business partners, A and B, jointly own property. C sues A alone to quiet title to that property. Must B be joined?

Common Mistakes

✕ Requiring relatedness for claims
Rule 18 has NO transaction test — any claim against an opposing party may be joined.
✕ Confusing Rule 20 with Rule 18
Parties need same transaction AND common question; claims do not.
✕ Forgetting jurisdiction
Proper joinder doesn't create subject-matter jurisdiction — analyze it separately.
✕ Missing compulsory counterclaims
A same-transaction counterclaim is waived if not pleaded with the answer.

Rule Summary

What It Joins Test
Rule 18(a)Claims vs. opposing partyNone (any claim)
Rule 20Parties (permissive)Same T/O + common Q
Rule 19Required partiesComplete relief / interest
Rule 13(a)Compulsory counterclaimSame T/O (or waived)
Rule 13(g)Crossclaim vs. co-partySame T/O

Question 1 of 5

P sues D for a 2022 breach of contract and wants to add an unrelated 2023 defamation claim against D. Which rule governs whether P may join the defamation claim?

Question 2 of 5

Under Rule 20, two or more plaintiffs may join in one action only if their claims satisfy which requirement(s)?

Question 3 of 5

D is sued and has a claim against P arising from the very same accident. D fails to assert it in the answer. What happens to D's claim?

Question 4 of 5

An absentee co-owner of disputed property is not joined, and adjudicating the case without her would impair her interest. A court that cannot join her must do what?

Question 5 of 5

P properly joins two claims against D under Rule 18(a), but one claim has no independent federal jurisdictional basis and no common nucleus of fact. What is true?