Intoxication
& Mistake
Apply the intoxication and mistake of fact defenses to negate the required mens rea of a crime.
What These Defenses Do
Intoxication and mistake are not affirmative justifications like self-defense. Instead, they work by negating an element of the offense, usually the defendant's required mental state.
Two Tiers of Mens Rea
Voluntary Intoxication
Voluntary intoxication results from the intentional use of a substance the defendant knows or should know is intoxicating.
Involuntary Intoxication
Involuntary intoxication occurs without the defendant's knowledge or against their will: trickery, duress, or an unexpected reaction to prescribed medication.
Intoxication Decision Path
Mistake of Fact
A mistake of fact is a defense if it negates the mens rea required for the crime. Whether the mistake must be reasonable depends on the intent level.
Mistake of Law
The general rule: ignorance of the law is no excuse. A mistake about whether conduct is illegal is generally not a defense.
Reasonable vs. Unreasonable
A Four-Step Approach
Example: Larceny
Drunk at a party, Dan takes a coat off the rack believing it is his own. He is charged with larceny, a specific-intent crime requiring intent to permanently deprive another of property.
Example: Battery
After heavy drinking, Erin swings her arm and strikes a stranger. She is charged with battery, a general-intent crime.
Example: Spiked Drink
Frank's drink is secretly spiked with a hallucinogen. Believing he is fighting a monster, he commits an assault, a general-intent crime.
Common Mistakes
Defense Summary
| Specific Intent | General / Malice | Strict Liability | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Voluntary Intox. | Defense | No | No |
| Involuntary Intox. | Defense | Defense | Defense |
| Mistake of Fact | Any mistake | Reasonable only | No |
| Mistake of Law | Rarely | Rarely | No |
Question 1 of 5
Drunk, Greg breaks into a house intending to steal a TV, charged with burglary (specific intent). What is the best analysis?
Question 2 of 5
Hal commits a general-intent battery while voluntarily intoxicated. Which is correct?
Question 3 of 5
Ida unreasonably but honestly believes a coat is hers and takes it, charged with larceny (specific intent). Result?
Question 4 of 5
Joe's coffee is secretly drugged; while disoriented he commits a general-intent assault. Best result?
Question 5 of 5
Ken honestly believes his conduct is legal but it violates a clear statute. He is charged. Best analysis?