Intervention
Joining an Existing Suit
When a non-party may inject itself into a pending lawsuit under Federal Rule 24 — and when the court must let them.
What Is Intervention?
Most joinder rules let a plaintiff bring others into a suit. Intervention flips that: it lets an outsider — a non-party — voluntarily enter a lawsuit that is already underway because the outcome will affect them.
The Outsider Joins the Suit
Two Types of Intervention
Intervention of Right — Rule 24(a)
Absent an unconditional statutory right, a non-party may intervene as of right only if the motion is timely AND all of the following are shown:
The Of-Right Test, Visually
Permissive Intervention — Rule 24(b)
When the of-right elements aren't all satisfied, a non-party may still ask the court for permission. The court has broad discretion.
Of Right vs. Permissive
| Of Right (a) | Permissive (b) | |
|---|---|---|
| Court's choice | Must allow | May allow |
| Interest required | Protectable interest | Common question only |
| Impairment shown | Required | Not required |
| Timeliness | Required | Required |
| Reviewed for | Each element de novo | Abuse of discretion |
The Adequacy Element
Element 3 of the of-right test — inadequate representation — is the easiest to satisfy. The applicant's burden is minimal.
How to Analyze Intervention
Example 1: The Insurer
A driver sues a manufacturer over a defective brake. The driver's insurance company — which has already paid the driver's medical bills and is subrogated to part of the claim — moves to intervene.
Example 2: The Late Neighbor
Two landowners litigate the boundary of a shared road. A neighbor with a possible easement learns of the suit but waits until after trial concludes to move to intervene.
Example 3: Parallel Claims
A consumer sues a company for false advertising. A second consumer with the same complaint but no special stake in the first consumer's recovery moves to intervene early.
Common Mistakes
Rule 24 Summary
| Element | 24(a) Right | 24(b) Permissive |
|---|---|---|
| Timely motion | ✓ Required | ✓ Required |
| Protectable interest | ✓ | ✕ |
| Impairment | ✓ | ✕ |
| Inadequate rep. | ✓ | ✕ |
| Common question | ✕ | ✓ |
| Result | Court MUST grant | Court MAY grant |
Question 1 of 5
Under Rule 24(a), which combination must a non-party establish for intervention of right (absent a statutory right)?
Question 2 of 5
A non-party files a motion to intervene one week after final judgment. The of-right elements are otherwise satisfied. The court should most likely:
Question 3 of 5
What is the key difference between Rule 24(a) and Rule 24(b)?
Question 4 of 5
A subrogated insurer moves to intervene in its insured's tort suit while the case is pending. This presents the strongest case for:
Question 5 of 5
Regarding the inadequate representation element of Rule 24(a), the applicant's burden is generally described as: