Intentional Defenses
How a defendant can avoid liability for an intentional tort — even when every element of the tort is proven.
What Is an Affirmative Defense?
An intentional tort plaintiff first proves the prima facie case — every element of the tort. But proving the tort is not the end. The defendant may raise an affirmative defense that defeats liability entirely.
The Core Defenses at a Glance
Where Defenses Fit in the Analysis
Defense 1: Consent
A plaintiff who validly consents cannot recover. Consent may be express (words) or implied (conduct or custom, e.g., contact sports).
Defense 2: Self-Defense
A person may use force that reasonably appears necessary to protect against an imminent threat. The force must be proportional to the threat faced.
The Deadly Force Limit
Self-Defense vs. Defense of Property
| Self-Defense | Defense of Property | |
|---|---|---|
| Protects | The person | Possessions |
| Deadly force? | Yes, if grave threat | Never |
| Warning first? | Not required | Usually required |
| Reasonable force | Required | Required |
How to Apply a Defense
Example 1: Consent on the Field
During a soccer match, Player A tackles Player B within the normal rules of play, causing a bruise. B sues for battery.
Example 2: Proportional Force
X shoves Y during an argument. Y responds by drawing a knife and stabbing X. X sues for battery; Y claims self-defense.
Example 3: Spring Gun Trap
A homeowner rigs a shotgun to fire at anyone who opens the cabin door while he is away. A trespasser opens the door and is seriously injured.
Common Mistakes
Defenses Summary
| Defense | Trigger | Key Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Consent | Plaintiff agreed | Valid & in scope |
| Self-Defense | Imminent threat to self | Proportional force |
| Defense of Others | Threat to a 3rd person | Reasonable force |
| Defense of Property | Threat to possessions | No deadly force |
Question 1 of 5
During a boxing match, A punches B within the rules, breaking B's nose. B sues for battery. What is the best defense?
Question 2 of 5
A landowner shoots and kills an unarmed trespasser who is merely walking across his field. Is defense of property a valid defense?
Question 3 of 5
M slaps N. N, who is much larger, responds by pulling a gun and shooting M. N claims self-defense. The likely result is:
Question 4 of 5
A patient consents to surgery on her right knee. The surgeon, seeing an issue, also operates on her left knee. The left-knee operation is:
Question 5 of 5
P consents to a friendly arm-wrestle, but D, intending to injure, twists P's arm and breaks it. The consent defense: