Injunctive Relief
Equitable Remedies
Learn how courts decide whether to order or forbid conduct when money damages simply will not do.
What Is an Injunction?
An injunction is an equitable remedy: a court order directing a party to do or refrain from doing a specific act. Unlike money damages, which are legal relief, injunctions are granted only when the legal remedy is inadequate.
Three Types by Timing
Two Directions of Command
The Four-Factor Permanent Injunction Test
A plaintiff seeking a permanent injunction must satisfy all four eBay v. MercExchange factors:
The Heart: Inadequate Remedy at Law
Legal damages are deemed inadequate when:
Preliminary Injunction: Likelihood of Success
For a preliminary injunction or TRO, the plaintiff must additionally show a likelihood of success on the merits, since the trial has not yet occurred.
Preliminary vs. Permanent
| Preliminary | Permanent | |
|---|---|---|
| When | Before trial | After full trial |
| Likelihood of success | Required | N/A (already won) |
| Bond | Usually required | Not required |
| Duration | Pendency of suit | Indefinite |
How to Analyze an Injunction Question
Equitable Defenses
Example 1: Unique Land
A buyer contracts to purchase a specific historic estate; the seller refuses to convey. The buyer sues for an injunction (specific performance).
Example 2: Balance of Hardships
A factory's overhang encroaches a few inches onto a neighbor's lot. Removing it would cost the factory millions; the neighbor's loss is trivial.
Example 3: Preliminary + Defense
A company seeks a preliminary injunction to stop a former employee from using trade secrets but waited two years, during which the employee built a business around them.
Common Mistakes
Summary Checklist
| Element | Question to Ask |
|---|---|
| Type | TRO, preliminary, or permanent? |
| Irreparable harm | Is the injury non-compensable? |
| Inadequate remedy | Will money fall short? |
| Balance | Whose hardship is greater? |
| Public interest | Does the order help or harm the public? |
| Defenses | Laches? Unclean hands? Impossible? |
Question 1 of 5
Which factor is unique to obtaining a preliminary injunction (not a permanent one)?
Question 2 of 5
A buyer sues to compel the sale of a one-of-a-kind painting. Why is an injunction (specific performance) likely?
Question 3 of 5
A plaintiff unreasonably delayed suing, prejudicing the defendant. Which defense bars equitable relief?
Question 4 of 5
A minor encroachment would cost the defendant millions to fix while barely benefiting the plaintiff. A court will most likely:
Question 5 of 5
Which type of injunction may be issued ex parte to preserve the status quo until a hearing?