01 / 20

The Incapacity
Defense

When a party lacks capacity to contract, the agreement may be voidable. Learn when incapacity excuses a promise.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Contractual Capacity?

Capacity is the legal ability to enter a binding contract. The law presumes adults of sound mind have full capacity. Certain protected classes, however, may lack it.

Three Protected Classes

Minors
Persons under 18. May disaffirm before, or shortly after, reaching majority.
Mental Illness
Those who cannot understand the nature and consequences of the transaction.
Intoxication
Severe impairment so the other party knew or should have known.

Void vs Voidable

VOID No legal effect from the start Neither party can enforce it VOIDABLE Valid unless disaffirmed The protected party chooses to cancel

The Infancy Doctrine

A minor (under 18 in most states) may disaffirm a contract at any time while still a minor and for a reasonable time after reaching majority.

1
Right to disaffirm. The minor — not the adult party — controls whether the contract stands.
2
Restitution. On disaffirmance the minor returns what remains in the minor's possession.
3
Necessaries exception. Minors are liable in quasi-contract for the reasonable value of necessaries (food, shelter, medical care).

Mental Illness & Intoxication

For mental incapacity, the test is whether the party could understand the nature and consequences of the transaction, or act reasonably in relation to it (and the other party had reason to know).

Disaffirm vs Ratify

Disaffirm
The protected party cancels the contract. Must occur during incapacity or within a reasonable time after it ends.
Ratify
After capacity is gained, the party affirms the contract — by words or conduct. Ratification permanently binds the party.

How to Apply the Defense

1
Identify the class. Is the party a minor, mentally ill, or intoxicated?
2
Test capacity. Apply the right standard (age vs. understanding nature/consequences).
3
Check exceptions. Necessaries? Other party's knowledge? Misrepresentation of age?
4
Determine election. Did the party disaffirm in time, or did they ratify?

Worked Example: The Used Car

Facts: 17-year-old Mia buys a used car for $4,000. Three months later she crashes it (now worth $1,000) and wants her money back.

Worked Example: Necessaries

Facts: 16-year-old Leo, living on his own, contracts for an apartment and groceries, then refuses to pay, claiming infancy.

Worked Example: Intoxication

Facts: At a sober business lunch, Dana — slightly tipsy — signs a clear, written sale of land. She later claims intoxication.

Common Mistakes

✕ Void vs Voidable
Treating an incapacity contract as void. It is voidable — valid until the protected party disaffirms.
✕ Who Can Disaffirm
Letting the adult escape. Only the party lacking capacity may avoid the contract.
✕ Forgetting Necessaries
Assuming a minor pays nothing. Reasonable value of necessaries is still owed.

Summary Comparison

Minor Mental / Intoxicated
TestUnder age 18Understands nature & consequences
EffectVoidableVoidable
NecessariesLiable (reasonable value)Liable (reasonable value)
Other party's knowledgeIrrelevantRequired for intoxication
RatificationAt majorityWhen capacity returns

Question 1 of 5

A contract entered by a party lacking capacity is generally:

Question 2 of 5

A 17-year-old buys a laptop and damages it. On disaffirmance in most jurisdictions, the minor:

Question 3 of 5

A minor contracts for emergency medical care. Which best describes the minor's liability?

Question 4 of 5

Greg's strongest argument that the contract is voidable is that:

Question 5 of 5

A person turns 18 and continues making payments and using a car bought as a minor. This conduct most likely amounts to:

Key Takeaways

1
Voidable, not void. Incapacity gives the protected party an election to disaffirm or ratify.
2
Necessaries always owed. Reasonable value, not the contract price, in quasi-contract.
3
Intoxication is narrow. Needs impairment and the other party's knowledge.
4
Watch the timing. Delay or continued use after capacity returns can ratify.

You've Mastered the Incapacity Defense

Identify the class, apply the right capacity test, check the exceptions, and resolve the party's election to disaffirm or ratify.