The Incapacity
Defense
When a party lacks capacity to contract, the agreement may be voidable. Learn when incapacity excuses a promise.
What Is Contractual Capacity?
Capacity is the legal ability to enter a binding contract. The law presumes adults of sound mind have full capacity. Certain protected classes, however, may lack it.
Three Protected Classes
Void vs Voidable
The Infancy Doctrine
A minor (under 18 in most states) may disaffirm a contract at any time while still a minor and for a reasonable time after reaching majority.
Mental Illness & Intoxication
For mental incapacity, the test is whether the party could understand the nature and consequences of the transaction, or act reasonably in relation to it (and the other party had reason to know).
Disaffirm vs Ratify
How to Apply the Defense
Worked Example: The Used Car
Facts: 17-year-old Mia buys a used car for $4,000. Three months later she crashes it (now worth $1,000) and wants her money back.
Worked Example: Necessaries
Facts: 16-year-old Leo, living on his own, contracts for an apartment and groceries, then refuses to pay, claiming infancy.
Worked Example: Intoxication
Facts: At a sober business lunch, Dana — slightly tipsy — signs a clear, written sale of land. She later claims intoxication.
Common Mistakes
Summary Comparison
| Minor | Mental / Intoxicated | |
|---|---|---|
| Test | Under age 18 | Understands nature & consequences |
| Effect | Voidable | Voidable |
| Necessaries | Liable (reasonable value) | Liable (reasonable value) |
| Other party's knowledge | Irrelevant | Required for intoxication |
| Ratification | At majority | When capacity returns |
Question 1 of 5
A contract entered by a party lacking capacity is generally:
Question 2 of 5
A 17-year-old buys a laptop and damages it. On disaffirmance in most jurisdictions, the minor:
Question 3 of 5
A minor contracts for emergency medical care. Which best describes the minor's liability?
Question 4 of 5
Facts: At a holiday party, Greg becomes heavily intoxicated. He signs a contract to sell his rare watch to Tom for far below market value. Tom had been drinking with Greg all evening and joked that Greg "would never agree to this sober."
Greg sobers up the next morning and immediately demands the watch back, refusing to deliver it.
Greg's strongest argument that the contract is voidable is that:
Question 5 of 5
A person turns 18 and continues making payments and using a car bought as a minor. This conduct most likely amounts to:
Key Takeaways
You've Mastered the Incapacity Defense
Identify the class, apply the right capacity test, check the exceptions, and resolve the party's election to disaffirm or ratify.