Impeachment Methods
How attorneys attack the credibility of a witness on cross-examination, and the rules that govern each technique.
What Is Impeachment?
Impeachment is the process of calling into question the credibility of a witness. It does not mean removing them from office: in the law of evidence, it means giving the jury a reason to doubt that the witness is telling the truth or remembers accurately.
Two Families of Attack
Non-Character Methods
Prior Inconsistent Statement
A prior inconsistent statement (PIS) is a statement the witness made earlier that conflicts with their current testimony. It shows the witness has not been consistent, and therefore may not be reliable.
Impeachment by Conviction
Specific Bad Acts
A witness may be cross-examined about prior bad acts that bear on truthfulness (lies, fraud, forgery) under FRE 608(b), if the act did not result in a conviction.
Key Distinction: Extrinsic Evidence
| Method | Extrinsic OK? | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Bias | Yes | after foundation |
| Prior inconsistent stmt | Yes | non-collateral only |
| Prior conviction | Yes | by certified record |
| Specific bad acts (608b) | No | stuck with answer |
| Reputation / opinion (608a) | Yes | call a character witness |
How to Apply It
Worked Example: Bias
Analysis: Both the family relationship and the payment show bias. Counsel may ask about them on cross. After giving the witness a chance to explain, counsel may also offer extrinsic evidence (e.g., the payment records) because bias is never collateral.
Worked Example: PIS
Analysis: The report is a prior inconsistent statement. It is admissible to impeach her credibility, and extrinsic proof of the report is allowed because the light color is non-collateral. But because it was not made under oath at a proceeding, it is NOT admissible substantively to prove the light was red.
Worked Example: Bad Act
Analysis: Lying on an application is a specific bad act probative of truthfulness, so the question is proper under FRE 608(b) with a good-faith basis. But the witness denied it, and 608(b) allows no extrinsic evidence. Counsel is stuck with the "No."
Common Mistakes
Method Summary
| Method | Type | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Bias / interest | Non-character | extrinsic OK, foundation |
| Sensory defect | Non-character | extrinsic OK |
| Prior inconsistent stmt | Non-character | truth only if sworn |
| Conviction (dishonesty) | Character | always in, 10-yr rule |
| Conviction (felony) | Character | balancing test |
| Bad acts (608b) | Character | no extrinsic |
| Reputation / opinion | Character | truthfulness only |
Quick Recap
Question 1 of 5
A witness denies, on cross, that she once forged a check. May counsel call a bank teller to prove the forgery (no conviction resulted)?
Question 2 of 5
A witness made an unsworn statement to police that conflicts with his trial testimony. For what purpose is it admissible?
Question 3 of 5
Which impeachment method is never considered collateral and always permits extrinsic evidence after a foundation?
Question 4 of 5
A witness has a felony conviction for assault that is 4 years old. How is its admissibility for impeachment determined?
Question 5 of 5
Under the modern Federal Rules, who may impeach a witness?