01 / 20

Impeachment Methods

How attorneys attack the credibility of a witness on cross-examination, and the rules that govern each technique.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Impeachment?

Impeachment is the process of calling into question the credibility of a witness. It does not mean removing them from office: in the law of evidence, it means giving the jury a reason to doubt that the witness is telling the truth or remembers accurately.

Two Families of Attack

Impeachment Non-Character attacks reliability Character attacks truthfulness Bias / Sensory defect Prior inconsistent statement Contradiction Reputation / opinion Specific bad acts Prior criminal convictions

Non-Character Methods

Bias / Interest
Witness has a motive to lie: relationship, payment, hostility, or stake in outcome.
Sensory Defect
Witness could not have perceived clearly: poor eyesight, distance, lighting, intoxication.
Contradiction
Other evidence shows the witness's testimony is simply factually wrong.

Prior Inconsistent Statement

A prior inconsistent statement (PIS) is a statement the witness made earlier that conflicts with their current testimony. It shows the witness has not been consistent, and therefore may not be reliable.

1
Always admissible to impeach. Any prior inconsistent statement may be used to attack credibility.
2
Substantive use is limited. A PIS comes in for the truth only if it was made under oath at a prior proceeding (FRE 801(d)(1)(A)).
3
Extrinsic evidence allowed on a non-collateral matter, with a chance to explain or deny.

Impeachment by Conviction

Prior Conviction Crime of dishonesty (false statement element) ALWAYS admissible no balancing test Felony (other) punishable > 1 year balancing test applies probative vs. prejudice

Specific Bad Acts

A witness may be cross-examined about prior bad acts that bear on truthfulness (lies, fraud, forgery) under FRE 608(b), if the act did not result in a conviction.

1
Must relate to truthfulness. A bar fight is not probative of honesty; embezzlement is.
2
Inquiry only — no extrinsic evidence. You ask the question, but you are stuck with the answer.
3
Good faith basis required. The cross-examiner must have a reasonable belief the act occurred.

Key Distinction: Extrinsic Evidence

Method Extrinsic OK? Note
BiasYesafter foundation
Prior inconsistent stmtYesnon-collateral only
Prior convictionYesby certified record
Specific bad acts (608b)Nostuck with answer
Reputation / opinion (608a)Yescall a character witness

How to Apply It

1
Identify the goal. Are you attacking reliability (non-character) or truthful nature (character)?
2
Pick the method. Bias, sensory defect, PIS, contradiction, conviction, bad act, or reputation.
3
Check the foundation. Most methods require giving the witness a chance to explain or deny.
4
Ask: is extrinsic evidence allowed? If the matter is collateral or it's a 608(b) bad act, the answer is no.

Worked Example: Bias

Analysis: Both the family relationship and the payment show bias. Counsel may ask about them on cross. After giving the witness a chance to explain, counsel may also offer extrinsic evidence (e.g., the payment records) because bias is never collateral.

Worked Example: PIS

Analysis: The report is a prior inconsistent statement. It is admissible to impeach her credibility, and extrinsic proof of the report is allowed because the light color is non-collateral. But because it was not made under oath at a proceeding, it is NOT admissible substantively to prove the light was red.

Worked Example: Bad Act

Analysis: Lying on an application is a specific bad act probative of truthfulness, so the question is proper under FRE 608(b) with a good-faith basis. But the witness denied it, and 608(b) allows no extrinsic evidence. Counsel is stuck with the "No."

Common Mistakes

✕ Extrinsic on 608(b)
Allowing outside proof of a bad act. You are stuck with the witness's answer.
✕ PIS as substance
Using an unsworn prior statement for its truth instead of just for impeachment.
✕ Any conviction qualifies
Forgetting the balancing test for non-dishonesty felonies and the 10-year rule.
✕ Forgetting foundation
Offering extrinsic bias or PIS evidence without a chance to explain or deny.

Method Summary

Method Type Limit
Bias / interestNon-characterextrinsic OK, foundation
Sensory defectNon-characterextrinsic OK
Prior inconsistent stmtNon-charactertruth only if sworn
Conviction (dishonesty)Characteralways in, 10-yr rule
Conviction (felony)Characterbalancing test
Bad acts (608b)Characterno extrinsic
Reputation / opinionCharactertruthfulness only

Quick Recap

Ask first
Character or non-character attack? That decides your method and limits.
Extrinsic?
608(b) bad acts and collateral matters = NO. Bias and PIS = YES.
Foundation
Give the witness a chance to explain or deny before extrinsic proof.

Question 1 of 5

A witness denies, on cross, that she once forged a check. May counsel call a bank teller to prove the forgery (no conviction resulted)?

Question 2 of 5

A witness made an unsworn statement to police that conflicts with his trial testimony. For what purpose is it admissible?

Question 3 of 5

Which impeachment method is never considered collateral and always permits extrinsic evidence after a foundation?

Question 4 of 5

A witness has a felony conviction for assault that is 4 years old. How is its admissibility for impeachment determined?

Question 5 of 5

Under the modern Federal Rules, who may impeach a witness?