Identification
Procedures
Evaluating how eyewitnesses identify suspects, and when due process bars unreliable identifications from trial.
What Are Identification Procedures?
An identification procedure is any method police use to have a witness identify a suspect as the perpetrator of a crime. Because eyewitness memory is fragile, the law scrutinizes these procedures closely.
Three Common Methods
Why It Matters
The Sixth Amendment Right
A suspect has a right to counsel at a post-charge lineup or showup. The right attaches once formal proceedings have begun (indictment, arraignment, or formal charge).
The Due Process Test
Any identification, of any type and at any stage, may be excluded if the procedure was unnecessarily suggestive and created a substantial likelihood of misidentification.
Reliability Factors
Right to Counsel vs. Due Process
These two challenges are independent. Master when each applies:
| 6th Amendment | Due Process | |
|---|---|---|
| Trigger | Post-charge lineup/showup | Suggestive procedure, any stage |
| Photo arrays? | No | Yes |
| Pre-charge? | No | Yes |
| Focus | Presence of counsel | Suggestiveness + reliability |
How to Analyze a Problem
Example 1: The Showup
Minutes after a robbery, police bring a handcuffed suspect to the victim, who immediately says, "That's him." No charges have been filed. Is this admissible?
Example 2: The Lineup
Example 3: In-Court ID
A pre-trial photo array is later found unduly suggestive. At trial, the witness identifies the defendant from the stand. Must the in-court ID be excluded?
Common Mistakes
Summary Table
| Method | 6th Am. Right? | Due Process? |
|---|---|---|
| Post-charge lineup | Yes | Yes |
| Post-charge showup | Yes | Yes |
| Pre-charge lineup | No | Yes |
| Photo array | No | Yes |
Question 1 of 5
At which procedure does a defendant have a Sixth Amendment right to counsel?
Question 2 of 5
A showup is challenged on due process grounds. Even if suggestive, the ID will be admitted if it is:
Question 3 of 5
Which is NOT a Neil v. Biggers reliability factor?
Question 4 of 5
A pre-trial photo array is found unduly suggestive. The witness wants to identify the defendant at trial. This in-court ID is permissible if:
Question 5 of 5
Police, before any charges, show a robbery victim a single handcuffed suspect minutes after the crime. The best argument to exclude this ID is: