01 / 20

Hearsay
Identification

Learn the test that decides whether an out-of-court statement is hearsay and inadmissible at trial.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Hearsay?

Under FRE 801(c), hearsay is a statement that meets two requirements at the same time:

1
Out-of-court statement. The declarant made the statement somewhere other than while testifying at the current trial or hearing.
2
Offered for its truth. A party offers it to prove that what the statement asserts is actually true.

Key Vocabulary

Declarant
The person who made the original statement.
Statement
An oral or written assertion, or nonverbal conduct intended as an assertion.
Truth of the Matter
Using the statement to prove its content is true.

Why It Matters

Hearsay is generally inadmissible because the opposing party cannot cross-examine the original declarant. We test a statement's reliability through four dangers:

Declarant reliability? Perception Memory Sincerity Narration

The Core Rule

We can express the test as a logical product. Let \( S \) be the statement. It is hearsay only when both factors are true:

$$ \text{Hearsay}(S) = \text{OutOfCourt}(S) \times \text{ForTruth}(S) $$

The Decision Flow

Is there a statement? Made out of court? Offered to prove its truth? YES NO HEARSAY (likely inadmissible) NOT HEARSAY (no truth purpose)

Truth vs. Non-Truth Purpose

The most tested issue is why a statement is offered. The same words can be hearsay or not, depending on the purpose.

For its Truth
"The light was red" — offered to prove the light was actually red. Hearsay.
Not for its Truth
Offered to show effect on the listener, notice, or that words were merely spoken. Not hearsay.

How to Apply the Test

1
Find the statement. Identify the assertion and who said it (the declarant).
2
Check location. Was it made outside this trial or hearing?
3
Ask the purpose. Is it offered to prove the matter asserted is true?
4
Conclude. Both yes \( \Rightarrow \) hearsay. Any no \( \Rightarrow \) not hearsay.

Example 1: Classic Hearsay

1
Statement: "The driver ran the stop sign" — an assertion. ✓
2
Out of court: The neighbor said it earlier, not on the stand. ✓
3
For its truth: Offered to prove the driver actually ran the sign. ✓

Example 2: Effect on Listener

1
Statement & out of court: Both met. ✓
2
For its truth? No — we don't care whether the floor was wet, only that the store heard the warning. ✕

Example 3: Verbal Act

1
Statement & out of court: Both met. ✓
2
For its truth? No — the words themselves have legal effect. Saying "I accept" is the acceptance. ✕

Common Mistakes

✕ Ignoring Purpose
Calling every out-of-court statement hearsay without asking why it is offered.
✕ Missing the Declarant
Forgetting that a witness's own earlier statement can still be hearsay.
✕ Conduct Confusion
Overlooking that assertive conduct (a nod, a point) counts as a statement.
✕ Truth Assumed
Treating effect-on-listener or notice statements as if offered for truth.

Summary Table

PurposeTruth?Hearsay?
Prove fact assertedYesHearsay
Effect on listenerNoNot hearsay
Notice / warningNoNot hearsay
Verbal act / legal effectNoNot hearsay
Impeachment by priorNoNot hearsay

Question 1 of 5

Which two elements must both be present for a statement to be hearsay?

Question 2 of 5

A witness repeats a 911 caller's statement only to show the police were notified of a crime. Is this hearsay?

Question 3 of 5

In a defamation case, a witness testifies the defendant said "You are a thief." Offered to prove the words were spoken. Hearsay?

Question 4 of 5

Is the shouted statement hearsay?

Question 5 of 5

A witness testifies that a customer pointed at a suspect to silently identify him. Offered to prove the suspect was the robber. Is the pointing hearsay?