01 / 20

Hearsay Exceptions
Declarant Unavailable

Apply the exceptions under FRE 804 that only open when the declarant cannot testify in person.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

Starting Point: What Is Hearsay?

Hearsay is an out-of-court statement offered to prove the truth of the matter asserted. It is generally inadmissible because the opposing party cannot cross-examine the person who said it.

Two Tracks of Exceptions

Hearsay Statement Is it admissible? FRE 803 Availability Immaterial FRE 804 Declarant Unavailable Works whether or not declarant can testify Requires the declarant to be legally unavailable

Defining Unavailability

Under FRE 804(a), a declarant is "unavailable" if any one of these conditions is met:

1
Privilege. The court rules the testimony is protected (e.g., self-incrimination).
2
Refusal. The declarant refuses to testify despite a court order.
3
Lack of memory. The declarant testifies to not remembering the subject matter.
4
Death or illness. The declarant cannot attend due to death or a then-existing condition.
5
Absence. The declarant is absent and the proponent cannot procure their attendance.

The Procurement Bar

There is a critical limit. The declarant is NOT considered unavailable if the proponent wrongfully caused the unavailability to prevent the declarant from testifying.

The Four 804(b) Exceptions

Former Testimony
Prior sworn testimony where the party had opportunity and motive to develop it.
Dying Declaration
A statement about the cause of impending death, believing death is imminent.
Statement Against Interest
A statement so contrary to the declarant's interest that only a truthful person would say it.
Forfeiture by Wrongdoing
A statement against a party who caused the declarant's unavailability.

Rule: Former Testimony

Prior Proceeding Sworn testimony given under oath Current Trial Testimony offered against same party Required Link Opportunity AND similar motive to develop the testimony before

Rule: Dying Declaration

Admissible in a homicide prosecution or any civil case. The statement must:

1
Concern the cause or circumstances of what the declarant believed to be their impending death.
2
Be made while believing death is imminent. The declarant need not actually die, but must believe death is near.

Rule: Statement Against Interest

A statement that, at the time it was made, was so contrary to the declarant's proprietary, pecuniary, or penal interest that a reasonable person would only have said it if true.

Distinction: Against Interest vs Party Admission

These are constantly confused. Pay attention to who said it and whether unavailability is needed.

Statement Against InterestParty Admission
Who made itAny declarantThe opposing party
UnavailabilityRequiredNot required
Against interest?Must be at time madeNot necessary
RuleFRE 804(b)(3)FRE 801(d)(2)

How to Apply the Rules

1
Is it hearsay? Out-of-court statement offered for its truth. If not, no exception is needed.
2
Check unavailability. Confirm the declarant fits one of the FRE 804(a) categories.
3
Rule out procurement. Did the proponent wrongfully cause the unavailability?
4
Match the exception. Apply the specific elements of the chosen 804(b) exception.

Example 1: Dying Declaration

1
Unavailable? Yes — death qualifies under FRE 804(a)(4).
2
Case type? Homicide prosecution — the rule applies.
3
Belief and subject? Imminent death belief + concerns the cause. Admissible. ✓

Example 2: Former Testimony

1
Unavailable? Yes — absent and cannot be procured (FRE 804(a)(5)).
2
Prior opportunity? Yes — defendant cross-examined with the same motive.
3
Former testimony exception satisfied. Admissible. ✓

Example 3: Forfeiture

1
Who caused the absence? The defendant — the party against whom it is offered.
2
Intent? The wrongdoing was designed to prevent testimony.
3
Forfeiture by wrongdoing applies — defendant forfeits the objection. Admissible. ✓

Common Mistakes

✕ Skipping Unavailability
Jumping to the 804(b) elements without first confirming the declarant is legally unavailable.
✕ Dying Declaration Scope
Applying it to all criminal cases — it only works in homicide and any civil case.
✕ Confusing Admissions
Treating a party admission as a statement against interest. Admissions need no unavailability.
✕ Ignoring Corroboration
Forgetting the corroboration requirement for penal-interest statements in criminal cases.

Summary: 804(b) Exceptions

ExceptionCore RequirementKey Limit
Former TestimonyPrior opportunity + motiveSame party / predecessor
Dying DeclarationBelief of imminent deathHomicide or civil only
Against InterestContrary to declarant's interestCorroboration if penal
ForfeitureParty caused unavailabilityIntent to silence

Question 1 of 5

Which condition does NOT make a declarant unavailable under FRE 804(a)?

Question 2 of 5

A dying declaration is admissible in which of the following?

Question 3 of 5

Under which exception is the transcript most likely admissible?

Question 4 of 5

A statement against the declarant's penal interest offered in a criminal case requires what additional showing?

Question 5 of 5

A defendant threatens a witness so she flees and cannot testify. The prosecution offers her prior statement. What is the result?