Hearsay Exceptions
Availability Immaterial
Master the exceptions under FRE 803 that apply whether or not the declarant is available to testify.
First, What Is Hearsay?
Hearsay is an out-of-court statement offered to prove the truth of the matter asserted. As a general rule, hearsay is inadmissible unless an exception applies.
Two Buckets of Exceptions
"Availability Immaterial"
For FRE 803 exceptions, it makes no difference whether the declarant is dead, missing, present, or even sitting in the witness chair. The statement comes in either way.
Present Sense Impression
Excited Utterance
Medical & State of Mind
Business & Public Records
803 vs. 804: The Key Distinction
| FRE 803 | FRE 804 | |
|---|---|---|
| Declarant availability | Immaterial | Must be unavailable |
| Reliability theory | Inherent reliability of the statement | Necessity (no other way to get it) |
| If declarant testifies | Still admissible | Exception unavailable |
| Example | Excited utterance | Dying declaration |
How to Apply It
Worked Example 1
Analysis: This is an excited utterance under 803(2): a startling event (the crash) produced a statement made under stress. Because 803 applies regardless of availability, the bystander's refusal to testify is irrelevant.
Worked Example 2
Analysis: The pain description and its cause are for medical diagnosis/treatment under 803(4). The cause ("fell off the ladder") is admissible because it is reasonably pertinent to treatment.
Worked Example 3
Analysis: This is a present sense impression under 803(1): a description of an event made while perceiving it. The probability that he had no time to fabricate is what makes it reliable.
Common Mistakes
FRE 803 Summary
| Exception | Rule | Trigger |
|---|---|---|
| Present Sense Impression | 803(1) | Made while/just after perceiving |
| Excited Utterance | 803(2) | Under stress of startling event |
| Then-Existing Condition | 803(3) | Present feeling or future intent |
| Medical Diagnosis | 803(4) | Made for treatment |
| Business Records | 803(6) | Regular course of business |
Question 1 of 5
Which condition is required for an FRE 803 exception to apply?
Question 2 of 5
A witness wants to repeat: "Right as it happened, she said the brakes failed." This is most likely admissible as a:
Question 3 of 5
A patient tells an ER physician, "My knee is throbbing because I twisted it during the game." Offered to prove the injury occurred, this is best admitted under:
Question 4 of 5
A declarant who made an excited utterance is now alive, present, and ready to testify. How does this affect admissibility under 803(2)?
Question 5 of 5
A company's accident report, prepared by its lawyer specifically for an anticipated lawsuit, is offered under 803(6). The likely result is: