Governing Law
Common Law vs. UCC
Before analyzing any contract, you must decide which body of law applies. The answer turns on what the contract is about.
Two Bodies of Contract Law
Every contract question begins with the same threshold step: identifying the governing law. On the bar, your entire analysis changes depending on which set of rules controls.
The Threshold Question
What Counts as Goods?
Under UCC §2-105, goods are all things that are movable at the time they are identified to the contract. Tangible, portable items.
The Core Rule
We can express this as a simple decision rule. Let \( G \) be the proposition "the contract is for a sale of goods":
$$ \text{Law} = \begin{cases} \text{UCC Art. 2} & \text{if } G \text{ is true} \\ \text{Common Law} & \text{if } G \text{ is false} \end{cases} $$
Mixed (Hybrid) Contracts
Many contracts involve both goods and services (e.g., installing a furnace). Courts apply the predominant purpose test: the law that governs the whole contract is the law of its dominant element.
Why the Choice Matters
| Common Law | UCC Article 2 | |
|---|---|---|
| Acceptance | Mirror image rule | Battle of the forms (§2-207) |
| Modification | Needs new consideration | Good faith; none needed |
| Missing terms | Often fatal to formation | Gap fillers supply terms |
| Statute of frauds | Various triggers | Goods \( \geq \$500 \) |
How to Apply It
Example 1: A Clear Case
Facts: Dana agrees to buy a used motorcycle from Eli for \( \$4{,}000 \).
Example 2: Services
Facts: A law firm hires a consultant to design a training program and deliver lectures for \( \$10{,}000 \).
Example 3: The Hybrid
Facts: A contractor agrees to supply a custom water heater (\( \$1{,}800 \)) and install it (\( \$300 \) labor) for one total price.
Common Mistakes
Quick Reference
| Subject Matter | Governing Law |
|---|---|
| Sale of a car or furniture | UCC Art. 2 |
| Employment / consulting | Common Law |
| Sale of land or a house | Common Law |
| Crops / livestock sale | UCC Art. 2 |
| Mixed goods + service | Predominant purpose |
Before the Assessment
Question 1 of 5
A buyer contracts to purchase 500 office chairs from a manufacturer. Which law governs?
Question 2 of 5
An accounting firm hires an attorney to provide ongoing legal advice for one year. Which law governs?
Question 3 of 5
A company agrees to buy a custom server (\( \$50{,}000 \)) plus on-site installation and setup (\( \$2{,}000 \)). Under the predominant purpose test, which law governs?
Question 4 of 5
A seller agrees to sell a farmhouse and the surrounding 40 acres of land. Which law governs?
Question 5 of 5
A buyer and seller dispute whether a contract modification is valid. Why does identifying the governing law matter for this issue?