01 / 20

Free Speech
Analysis

Apply speech regulation frameworks under the First Amendment: from content-based scrutiny to unprotected categories and forum analysis.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What the First Amendment Protects

The First Amendment bars the government from "abridging the freedom of speech." But not all speech is equal, and not all government action triggers the same scrutiny. Analysis begins by asking two questions.

1
Is the regulation content-based or content-neutral? This determines the level of scrutiny.
2
Is the speech protected or unprotected? Some categories receive little or no protection.

Content-Based vs. Content-Neutral

Content-Based Content-Neutral Targets the message, subject, or viewpoint Targets time, place, or manner only Strict Scrutiny compelling + narrowly tailored Intermediate Scrutiny important + narrowly tailored

Categories of Unprotected Speech

Incitement
Directed to producing imminent lawless action and likely to do so (Brandenburg).
Fighting Words
Words that by their utterance tend to provoke an immediate breach of peace.
True Threats
Serious expression of intent to commit unlawful violence.
Obscenity
Fails the three-part Miller test for prurient, patently offensive material.
Defamation
False statements of fact causing reputational harm.

The Strict Scrutiny Standard

A content-based restriction on protected speech survives only if the government proves it is necessary to achieve a compelling interest using the least restrictive means:

In practice, the probability that a content-based law survives is low: \( P(\text{survive}) \approx 0 \). The burden rests entirely on the government.

Time, Place & Manner: Intermediate Test

Content-neutral restrictions in a public forum are valid if they satisfy three requirements:

1
Content-neutral on its face and in purpose.
2
Narrowly tailored to serve a significant (important) government interest.
3
Leaves open ample alternative channels of communication.

Forum Analysis

Traditional / Designated Limited Public Nonpublic Streets, parks Opened for limited topics Military bases, airports Strict for content-based Reasonable + viewpoint-neutral Reasonable + viewpoint-neutral

A Step-by-Step Approach

1
State action? Confirm the government is the regulator.
2
Protected speech? Check for unprotected categories first.
3
Content-based or neutral? Pick the scrutiny level.
4
Forum? Where does the speech occur?
5
Apply the test and check for overbreadth or vagueness.

Worked Example: Park Ordinance

A city bans all amplified sound in public parks after 10 p.m. to protect residents' sleep. A protest group challenges it. Is the ban valid?

1
Public park = traditional public forum.
2
The ban applies regardless of message = content-neutral.
3
Quiet at night is significant; daytime speech remains = ample alternatives.

Worked Example: Targeting a Topic

A statute bans demonstrations "concerning labor disputes" on public sidewalks but allows all other demonstrations. A union sues.

1
Sidewalk = traditional public forum.
2
Singling out a subject (labor) = content-based.
3
Triggers strict scrutiny: compelling interest + least restrictive means.

Worked Example: Incitement?

A speaker at a rally states the government is corrupt and says, vaguely, "someday we may have to take action." Prosecutors charge him with incitement.

Common Mistakes

✕ Skipping forum analysis
The standard for content-neutral laws shifts depending on the type of forum.
✕ Confusing scrutiny levels
Content-based gets strict; content-neutral gets intermediate.
✕ Ignoring state action
Private restrictions raise no First Amendment claim.
✕ Calling all offensive speech unprotected
Offensive speech is usually protected unless it fits a narrow category.

Scrutiny Summary

Content-BasedContent-Neutral
ScrutinyStrictIntermediate
Interest requiredCompellingSignificant / important
TailoringLeast restrictive meansNarrowly tailored
AlternativesNot the focusMust remain open
Likely outcomeUsually invalidOften valid

Question 1 of 5

A city ordinance bans posting signs "that criticize city officials" on lampposts. What scrutiny applies?

Question 2 of 5

Which test governs whether advocacy of illegal conduct may be punished as incitement?

Question 3 of 5

Why is the university's exclusion most likely unconstitutional?

Question 4 of 5

A statute bans all leafletting in airport terminals to reduce litter. Which element is most likely the law's weakest point under intermediate scrutiny?

Question 5 of 5

A private shopping mall ejects a protester distributing flyers. The protester sues, claiming a free-speech violation. What is the strongest defense?

Putting It Together

You Can Now Analyze Speech

You can identify state action, classify regulations, run forum analysis, and apply the correct scrutiny standard with confidence.