01 / 20

Fiduciary Duties
in Agency Law

Identify the duties owed by an agent to a principal — and the duties owed in return.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Fiduciary?

A fiduciary is a person who agrees to act on behalf of another, placing the other person's interests above their own. The relationship is built on trust and confidence.

The Principal–Agent Relationship

PRINCIPAL Grants authority AGENT Acts on behalf Authority Fiduciary duties

Why Fiduciary Duties Matter

Protects Principals
Agents often control money, property, and decisions on the principal's behalf.
Imposes Liability
Breach allows the principal to recover damages, profits, or rescind transactions.
Tested Heavily
Bar exam questions frequently test whether a duty was breached and its remedy.

The Agent's Core Duties

1
Duty of Loyalty. Act solely for the principal's benefit; avoid conflicts and self-dealing.
2
Duty of Care. Act with reasonable care, competence, and diligence.
3
Duty of Obedience. Follow the principal's lawful and reasonable instructions.
4
Duty to Disclose. Provide material information and account for funds.

Rule: Duty of Loyalty

The agent must act solely for the benefit of the principal in all matters connected with the agency, and must not use the position for personal gain.

No Self-Dealing
Cannot deal with the principal as an adverse party without consent.
No Secret Profits
Must disgorge any undisclosed profit earned through the agency.
No Competing
Cannot compete with the principal regarding the subject matter.

Rule: Duty of Care

The agent must act with the care, competence, and diligence normally exercised by agents in similar circumstances. The standard scales with the agent's special skills.

Key Distinction: Loyalty vs. Care

Duty of LoyaltyDuty of Care
ConcernConflicts of interestCompetence & diligence
Breach bySelf-dealing, secret profitCarelessness, negligence
RemedyDisgorgement, rescissionCompensatory damages
Waivable?Only with full disclosureBy agreement (limited)

The Principal's Duties

The principal is generally not a fiduciary, but owes the agent contractual and good-faith duties.

1
Compensation. Pay the agent as agreed for services rendered.
2
Reimbursement & Indemnification. Cover expenses and losses incurred on the principal's behalf.
3
Cooperation. Deal fairly, in good faith, and not interfere with the agent's performance.

How to Analyze a Duty Problem

1
Identify the relationship. Confirm an agency exists and who is the agent vs. principal.
2
Name the duty at issue. Loyalty, care, obedience, or disclosure.
3
Check for consent. Full disclosure + informed consent can cure a loyalty conflict.
4
State the remedy. Damages, disgorgement, or rescission as appropriate.

Example 1: Secret Profit

Facts: An agent hired to buy land for the principal secretly buys it first, then resells it to the principal at a markup, pocketing \( \$10{,}000 \).

Example 2: Negligent Agent

Facts: A stockbroker-agent fails to execute a sale the principal instructed, causing the principal to lose \( \$5{,}000 \) when the stock drops.

Example 3: Cured Conflict

Facts: An agent wants to sell her own property to the principal. She fully discloses her ownership and the price, and the principal consents in writing.

Common Mistakes

✕ Principal Is a Fiduciary
The principal is generally NOT a fiduciary of the agent — only the agent owes fiduciary duties.
✕ Consent Without Disclosure
Consent only cures a loyalty conflict if it follows full disclosure of all material facts.
✕ Wrong Remedy
Loyalty breaches allow disgorgement; care breaches typically give only compensatory damages.

Duties Summary

DutyOwed ByCore Requirement
LoyaltyAgentAct solely for principal; no self-dealing
CareAgentReasonable competence & diligence
ObedienceAgentFollow lawful instructions
DisclosureAgentShare material info; account for funds
CompensationPrincipalPay, reimburse, cooperate

Question 1 of 5

Which party in an agency relationship owes fiduciary duties to the other?

Question 2 of 5

An agent earns an undisclosed \( \$3{,}000 \) commission from a third party while acting for the principal. Which duty is breached?

Question 3 of 5

An agent wants to buy property from the principal for himself. What makes the transaction permissible?

Question 4 of 5

A professional agent with special expertise is held to what standard under the duty of care?

Question 5 of 5

An agent ignores the principal's lawful instruction to sell, causing a \( \$5{,}000 \) loss. Which duty is breached and what is the remedy?