Expert Testimony
Rules of Evidence
When can a witness offer an opinion? Learn how courts decide whether expert testimony may be admitted under the Federal Rules of Evidence.
What Is Expert Testimony?
Most witnesses can only testify to what they personally observed. An expert witness is different: because of specialized knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education, an expert may give an opinion to help the jury understand complex evidence.
Two Kinds of Witnesses
Why It Matters
The Core Rule: FRE 702
A witness qualified as an expert may testify in the form of an opinion if all four requirements are met:
Step One: Qualification
Before reliability is even reached, the witness must be qualified as an expert. Qualification can come from any of five sources:
Reliability: The Daubert Factors
In federal courts, the judge as gatekeeper assesses reliability using non-exclusive Daubert factors:
Daubert vs. Frye
| Daubert | Frye | |
|---|---|---|
| Used by | Federal courts & many states | Some states |
| Standard | Reliability (multi-factor) | General acceptance only |
| Judge's role | Active gatekeeper | Limited inquiry |
| Flexibility | Flexible, case-by-case | Rigid single test |
Basis of the Opinion: FRE 703
An expert may base an opinion on facts that are not themselves admissible, as long as experts in the field would reasonably rely on such data.
How to Apply the Test
Worked Example One
A toxicologist with a PhD testifies that a chemical caused the plaintiff's illness, using a peer-reviewed, generally accepted method with a known error rate.
Worked Example Two
A self-proclaimed "psychic detective" offers to testify that the defendant is guilty based on intuition. The method has never been tested, published, or accepted.
Worked Example Three
A board-certified surgeon testifies about real estate valuation in a property dispute, relying only on a single online listing.
Common Mistakes
Quick Reference
| Rule | Governs | Key Point |
|---|---|---|
| FRE 701 | Lay opinion | No specialized knowledge |
| FRE 702 | Expert opinion | 4 reliability prongs |
| FRE 703 | Basis of opinion | Reasonable reliance |
| Daubert | Reliability test | Judge as gatekeeper |
Question 1 of 5
Which Federal Rule of Evidence primarily governs the admissibility of expert opinion testimony?
Question 2 of 5
Under Daubert, which is NOT one of the factors a court considers for reliability?
Question 3 of 5
A mechanic with no college degree but 25 years of experience repairing engines is offered as an expert to explain why a car's brakes failed. The opposing party objects, arguing the mechanic lacks formal education.
How should the court rule on the objection?
Question 4 of 5
A physician bases her opinion partly on a nurse's hearsay notes that were never admitted into evidence. Is this proper under FRE 703?
Question 5 of 5
A board-certified cardiologist is offered to testify about fingerprint identification using a method with no error rate and no peer review. The best basis for exclusion is that the testimony: