01 / 20

The Exclusionary Rule
Suppressing Illegal Evidence

Evidence obtained in violation of the Fourth, Fifth, or Sixth Amendment is generally barred from the prosecution's case-in-chief. Master the rule and its key exceptions.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is the Exclusionary Rule?

The exclusionary rule is a judge-made remedy that prevents the government from using illegally obtained evidence against a defendant in a criminal trial. Its purpose is to deter police misconduct by removing the incentive to violate constitutional rights.

Key Terms to Know

Suppression
A court order keeping evidence out of the prosecution's case-in-chief.
Fruit of the Poisonous Tree
Evidence derived from an initial illegal act is also tainted and excludable.
Standing
Only a person whose own rights were violated may move to suppress.

Why the Rule Matters

Illegal Search Evidence Obtained Suppressed at Trial Deters future misconduct

The Core Rule

1
Direct evidence. The physical thing or statement obtained illegally is excluded.
2
Derivative evidence. The "fruit of the poisonous tree": leads, witnesses, or items discovered because of the illegal act are also excluded.

Fruit of the Poisonous Tree

Illegal Arrest (the "poisonous tree") Confession given during detention Weapon found from confession's lead All "fruit" of the illegal arrest is excluded unless an exception breaks the chain

The Key Exceptions

Independent Source
Evidence was also obtained through a separate, lawful source untainted by the illegality.
Inevitable Discovery
Police would have lawfully found the evidence anyway through routine procedures.
Attenuation
The link between the illegality and the evidence is so weak the taint dissipates.

The Good-Faith Exception

Evidence is not excluded when officers reasonably and in good faith rely on a search warrant that is later found defective. Because there is no police misconduct to deter, suppression serves no purpose.

Independent Source vs. Inevitable Discovery

Independent Source Inevitable Discovery
Question asked Was it actually found another way? Would it have been found anyway?
Time frame A real, separate lawful path existed A hypothetical lawful path
Proof Actual independent discovery Routine procedure would reveal it

How to Apply the Rule

1
Identify the violation. Was a Fourth, Fifth, or Sixth Amendment right breached by government action?
2
Check standing. Only the person whose own rights were violated may move to suppress.
3
Trace the fruit. Is this direct or derivative evidence of the violation?
4
Apply exceptions. Independent source, inevitable discovery, attenuation, or good faith?
5
Check the use. Is the offer for the case-in-chief, or a permitted use like impeachment?

Where the Rule Does Not Apply

Grand Jury
Witnesses may be questioned based on illegally obtained evidence.
Impeachment
Illegally obtained statements can impeach a testifying defendant.
Civil & Parole
Generally inapplicable to civil cases and parole revocation hearings.

Worked Example: Direct Suppression

Police search Dan's home without a warrant and no exception applies. They find a bag of cocaine. The prosecution wants to admit the cocaine to prove possession.

Worked Example: Inevitable Discovery

Police illegally question Eve, who reveals where a body is hidden. However, a 200-volunteer search team was already systematically grid-searching that exact area and would have reached the body within hours.

Worked Example: Attenuation

Police illegally arrest Frank. Days later, after release, Frank voluntarily returns to the station on his own and confesses without prompting.

Common Mistakes

✕ Ignoring Standing
A defendant cannot suppress evidence found by violating someone else's rights.
✕ Total Ban Assumption
Excluded evidence can still be used for impeachment and before a grand jury.
✕ Confusing Source Tests
Independent source = actually found lawfully; inevitable discovery = would have been.
✕ Overusing Good Faith
No good faith where the warrant is facially defective or based on a lying officer.

Exceptions Summary

Exception Trigger Result
Independent Source Truly separate lawful discovery Admitted
Inevitable Discovery Would be found anyway Admitted
Attenuation Taint dissipates over time/will Admitted
Good Faith Reasonable reliance on warrant Admitted

Question 1 of 5

What is the primary purpose of the exclusionary rule?

Question 2 of 5

Police find a weapon based on a lead from an illegally obtained confession. The weapon is best described as:

Question 3 of 5

Will the evidence likely be suppressed?

Question 4 of 5

A defendant testifies and lies on the stand. The prosecution wants to use his illegally obtained statement to contradict him. This is:

Question 5 of 5

Police illegally enter Gina's apartment and find evidence implicating her roommate, Hal. Hal moves to suppress. The motion will likely: