The Exclusionary Rule
Suppressing Illegal Evidence
Evidence obtained in violation of the Fourth, Fifth, or Sixth Amendment is generally barred from the prosecution's case-in-chief. Master the rule and its key exceptions.
What Is the Exclusionary Rule?
The exclusionary rule is a judge-made remedy that prevents the government from using illegally obtained evidence against a defendant in a criminal trial. Its purpose is to deter police misconduct by removing the incentive to violate constitutional rights.
Key Terms to Know
Why the Rule Matters
The Core Rule
Fruit of the Poisonous Tree
The Key Exceptions
The Good-Faith Exception
Evidence is not excluded when officers reasonably and in good faith rely on a search warrant that is later found defective. Because there is no police misconduct to deter, suppression serves no purpose.
Independent Source vs. Inevitable Discovery
| Independent Source | Inevitable Discovery | |
|---|---|---|
| Question asked | Was it actually found another way? | Would it have been found anyway? |
| Time frame | A real, separate lawful path existed | A hypothetical lawful path |
| Proof | Actual independent discovery | Routine procedure would reveal it |
How to Apply the Rule
Where the Rule Does Not Apply
Worked Example: Direct Suppression
Police search Dan's home without a warrant and no exception applies. They find a bag of cocaine. The prosecution wants to admit the cocaine to prove possession.
Worked Example: Inevitable Discovery
Police illegally question Eve, who reveals where a body is hidden. However, a 200-volunteer search team was already systematically grid-searching that exact area and would have reached the body within hours.
Worked Example: Attenuation
Police illegally arrest Frank. Days later, after release, Frank voluntarily returns to the station on his own and confesses without prompting.
Common Mistakes
Exceptions Summary
| Exception | Trigger | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Independent Source | Truly separate lawful discovery | Admitted |
| Inevitable Discovery | Would be found anyway | Admitted |
| Attenuation | Taint dissipates over time/will | Admitted |
| Good Faith | Reasonable reliance on warrant | Admitted |
Question 1 of 5
What is the primary purpose of the exclusionary rule?
Question 2 of 5
Police find a weapon based on a lead from an illegally obtained confession. The weapon is best described as:
Question 3 of 5
Officers obtain a search warrant from a neutral magistrate. The warrant later turns out to lack probable cause, but the officers reasonably believed it was valid and executed it in objective good faith. The warrant was not facially defective and the supporting affidavit was not knowingly false.
Will the evidence likely be suppressed?
Question 4 of 5
A defendant testifies and lies on the stand. The prosecution wants to use his illegally obtained statement to contradict him. This is:
Question 5 of 5
Police illegally enter Gina's apartment and find evidence implicating her roommate, Hal. Hal moves to suppress. The motion will likely: