01 / 20

Ex Post Facto
Laws

The Constitution forbids punishing conduct that was legal when it happened. Learn to spot and apply ex post facto protections.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is an Ex Post Facto Law?

An ex post facto law (Latin: "from a thing done afterward") is a criminal law that operates retroactively to a person's disadvantage. The Constitution bars both Congress and the states from passing them.

The Core Idea: Timing

time Act done (legal then) New law (criminalizes it) Reaching back = forbidden

Two Threshold Requirements

1
Retroactive: the law applies to conduct that occurred before the law was enacted.
2
Criminal & disadvantageous: the law is penal in nature and works to the defendant's detriment.

The Four Calder Categories

Calder v. Bull (1798) defined four kinds of forbidden retroactive criminal laws:

1
Criminalizes conduct that was innocent when done.
2
Aggravates a crime, making it greater than it was when committed.
3
Increases the punishment for a crime after it was committed.
4
Alters the rules of evidence to make conviction easier.

The Test as a Condition

Retroactive? before enactment Criminal / punitive? Disadvantage to D? AND AND VIOLATION

Don't Confuse It With Bills of Attainder

Ex Post Facto
Punishes conduct retroactively. Focus is on timing: criminalizing or worsening punishment for past acts.
Bill of Attainder
A legislative act that punishes a specific person or group without a trial. Focus is on who and no judicial process.

Civil Laws Are Outside the Clause

The Ex Post Facto Clause applies only to criminal/penal laws. Retroactive civil legislation (taxes, licensing, procedure) is analyzed under Due Process, not ex post facto.

How to Apply the Protection

1
Identify the timing. Did the law take effect after the defendant's conduct?
2
Classify the law. Is it criminal/punitive, or genuinely civil?
3
Check the effect. Does it criminalize, aggravate, increase punishment, or ease conviction?
4
Check direction. Does it disadvantage the defendant? Beneficial changes are permitted.

Worked Example: Increased Sentence

In 2020, the penalty for theft was 5 years max. Dana committed theft in 2020. In 2022, the legislature raised the maximum to 10 years and applied it to pending cases.

Worked Example: Reduced Penalty

After Marco's offense but before sentencing, the legislature lowered the penalty for his crime and made the reduction retroactive.

Worked Example: Evidence Rules

A state amends its rules so that uncorroborated testimony of one witness now suffices to convict, where two witnesses were previously required. It applies the change to a pending prosecution.

Common Mistakes

✕ Applying it to civil laws
The clause covers only criminal/penal laws. Retroactive civil laws fall under Due Process.
✕ Forgetting "disadvantage"
Retroactive laws that help the defendant (lighter penalties) are perfectly constitutional.
✕ Confusing with attainder
Ex post facto is about timing; bill of attainder is punishing a named person without trial.
✕ Ignoring procedure exception
Procedural changes that don't disadvantage the defendant are allowed even if retroactive.

Quick Reference Table

Retroactive law Result
Criminalizes innocent actCriminal, hurts DViolation
Increases punishmentCriminal, hurts DViolation
Eases conviction (evidence)Criminal, hurts DViolation
Reduces punishmentCriminal, helps DAllowed
Retroactive tax / civil ruleCivilAllowed

Question 1 of 5

A statute raises the maximum prison term for a robbery committed last year and applies it to that defendant. Is this an ex post facto violation?

Question 2 of 5

A legislature retroactively lowers the sentence for an offense and applies it to a pending case. The defendant benefits. Constitutional?

Question 3 of 5

A new state law imposes a retroactive property tax on transactions completed two years ago. Which clause governs the challenge?

Question 4 of 5

Congress passes a law naming a specific former official and barring him from federal employment as punishment, with no trial. This is best described as a:

Question 5 of 5

A state changes its evidence rule so that one witness (instead of two) can support a conviction, applying it to crimes already committed. The change makes conviction easier. Result?

Key Takeaways

1
The clause bars retroactive criminal laws that disadvantage the defendant.
2
Four Calder categories: criminalize, aggravate, increase punishment, ease conviction.
3
It does not apply to civil laws or to changes that help the defendant.
4
Don't confuse it with the bill of attainder protection.