The Erie
Doctrine
When a federal court sits in diversity jurisdiction, which law governs — federal or state? Master the framework that decides.
What Is the Erie Doctrine?
The Erie doctrine answers a single, recurring question: when a federal court hears a case based on diversity of citizenship, must it apply federal law or state law to a given issue?
Key Terms
Why It Matters
Before Erie, the outcome of a case could depend purely on which courthouse a plaintiff chose. This invited forum shopping and unequal treatment of litigants.
The Core Split
The Core Rule
Erie rests on a constitutional foundation: under the Rules of Decision Act and the principles of federalism, federal courts may not displace state-created substantive rights simply because of diversity jurisdiction.
Step One: Is There a Federal Directive?
The modern analysis is hierarchical. First ask whether a federal directive — the Constitution, a federal statute, or a Federal Rule of Civil Procedure — directly governs the issue.
Step Two: No Directive On Point
If no federal directive controls, the court applies judge-made tests to decide whether the issue is substantive (state law) or procedural (federal law):
Always vs. Sometimes State Law
How to Apply Erie
Example 1: Statute of Limitations
Facts: A diversity case is filed in federal court. The relevant state statute of limitations is 2 years; there is no federal directive on point.
Example 2: A Valid FRCP Conflicts
Facts: State law requires that a complaint be served within 60 days, but FRCP 4(m) allows 90 days for service. The two directly conflict.
Example 3: The Gray Zone
Facts: State law caps damages for a tort claim. No FRCP addresses damage caps. The defendant argues the cap is "merely procedural."
Common Mistakes
Summary Table
| Issue | Classification | Law Applied |
|---|---|---|
| Statute of limitations | Substantive | State |
| Elements of a claim | Substantive | State |
| Damages caps | Substantive | State |
| Valid FRCP on point | Procedural | Federal |
| Pleading / discovery rules | Procedural | Federal |
Question 1 of 5
A federal court hears a tort claim under diversity jurisdiction. Which law governs the elements of negligence?
Question 2 of 5
Under the modern analysis, what is the first question a court asks in an Erie problem?
Question 3 of 5
A valid Federal Rule of Civil Procedure directly conflicts with a state rule in a diversity case. What happens?
Question 4 of 5
In a diversity case with no federal directive, the state statute of limitations differs from the period the federal court would otherwise use. Which applies?
Question 5 of 5
Which of the following best states the twin aims of the Erie doctrine?