01 / 20

The Erie
Doctrine

When a federal court sits in diversity jurisdiction, which law governs — federal or state? Master the framework that decides.

Bar Exam

What Is the Erie Doctrine?

The Erie doctrine answers a single, recurring question: when a federal court hears a case based on diversity of citizenship, must it apply federal law or state law to a given issue?

Key Terms

Diversity Jurisdiction
Federal court power over disputes between citizens of different states where the amount exceeds \(\$75,000\).
Substantive Law
Rules defining rights and duties — e.g., negligence standards, statutes of limitations.
Procedural Law
Rules governing how a case proceeds — pleadings, service, discovery, jury rules.

Why It Matters

Before Erie, the outcome of a case could depend purely on which courthouse a plaintiff chose. This invited forum shopping and unequal treatment of litigants.

The Core Split

Federal Court in Diversity Case Substantive Issue Apply STATE law Procedural Issue Apply FEDERAL law The hard cases live in the gray zone between "substance" and "procedure."

The Core Rule

Erie rests on a constitutional foundation: under the Rules of Decision Act and the principles of federalism, federal courts may not displace state-created substantive rights simply because of diversity jurisdiction.

Step One: Is There a Federal Directive?

The modern analysis is hierarchical. First ask whether a federal directive — the Constitution, a federal statute, or a Federal Rule of Civil Procedure — directly governs the issue.

Step Two: No Directive On Point

If no federal directive controls, the court applies judge-made tests to decide whether the issue is substantive (state law) or procedural (federal law):

1
Outcome-determinative test. Would applying federal instead of state law significantly affect the outcome?
2
Twin aims test. Would using federal law encourage forum shopping or cause inequitable administration of the laws?
3
Balancing test. Weigh the federal judicial interest against the state's interest in its rule.

Always vs. Sometimes State Law

Always State Law
Statutes of limitations, tolling rules, elements of a claim or defense, choice-of-law rules, standards of care.
Always Federal Law
Matters squarely covered by a valid FRCP, federal statute, or the Constitution.

How to Apply Erie

1
Confirm diversity jurisdiction. Erie applies in diversity (state-law) cases, not federal-question cases.
2
Look for a federal directive on point. If a valid Constitution / statute / FRCP applies, it controls.
3
If none, run the tests. Outcome-determinative + twin aims + balancing.
4
Classify. Substantive → state law. Procedural → federal law.

Example 1: Statute of Limitations

Facts: A diversity case is filed in federal court. The relevant state statute of limitations is 2 years; there is no federal directive on point.

Example 2: A Valid FRCP Conflicts

Facts: State law requires that a complaint be served within 60 days, but FRCP 4(m) allows 90 days for service. The two directly conflict.

Example 3: The Gray Zone

Facts: State law caps damages for a tort claim. No FRCP addresses damage caps. The defendant argues the cap is "merely procedural."

Common Mistakes

✕ Applying Erie in Federal-Question Cases
Erie governs diversity cases. Federal-question cases use federal substantive law.
✕ Skipping the Directive Step
Always check for a valid federal directive first — it short-circuits the balancing tests.
✕ Calling SOL "Procedural"
Statutes of limitations are substantive for Erie; apply the state period.

Summary Table

Issue Classification Law Applied
Statute of limitationsSubstantiveState
Elements of a claimSubstantiveState
Damages capsSubstantiveState
Valid FRCP on pointProceduralFederal
Pleading / discovery rulesProceduralFederal

Question 1 of 5

A federal court hears a tort claim under diversity jurisdiction. Which law governs the elements of negligence?

Question 2 of 5

Under the modern analysis, what is the first question a court asks in an Erie problem?

Question 3 of 5

A valid Federal Rule of Civil Procedure directly conflicts with a state rule in a diversity case. What happens?

Question 4 of 5

In a diversity case with no federal directive, the state statute of limitations differs from the period the federal court would otherwise use. Which applies?

Question 5 of 5

Which of the following best states the twin aims of the Erie doctrine?