01 / 20

Equitable Remedies
Specific Performance

When money damages won't do, courts may order a party to actually perform the contract. Learn when this powerful remedy is available.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Are Equitable Remedies?

Courts grant two broad categories of relief. Legal remedies compensate with money: damages. Equitable remedies are non-monetary court orders that compel or forbid specific conduct.

Two Roads After a Breach

Breach of Contract Legal Remedy Money Damages Equitable Remedy Specific Performance Default remedy Only when money is inadequate

Why It Matters

Unique Goods
Land, art, and heirlooms cannot be bought elsewhere. Money cannot replace them.
Honoring Promises
Equity ensures parties actually receive the performance they bargained for.
Bar Exam Focus
A recurring contracts issue: can the plaintiff compel performance, or only collect cash?

The Core Rule

The single most-tested element is the inadequacy of money damages. If damages would fully compensate, the court will refuse specific performance.

The Five Elements

1
Valid contract. A binding agreement with definite and certain terms the court can enforce.
2
Conditions satisfied. The plaintiff has performed or is ready, willing, and able to perform.
3
Inadequate legal remedy. Money damages cannot make the plaintiff whole (e.g., the subject matter is unique).
4
Feasibility of enforcement. The court can practically supervise and enforce the order.
5
No equitable defenses. No laches, unclean hands, hardship, or unfairness that bars relief.

When Damages Are Inadequate

Land
Every parcel is legally unique. Land sale contracts almost always qualify for specific performance.
Unique Goods
Art, antiques, custom items, and rare goods cannot be replaced on the market.
Ordinary Goods
Mass-produced, replaceable goods: cover purchase plus damages is adequate. No specific performance.

Specific Performance vs. Injunction

Specific Performance Injunction
Nature of orderCompels affirmative actCompels or forbids conduct
Typical useForce completion of a saleRestrain a competing act
Personal servicesGenerally deniedMay enjoin breach indirectly
Common contextLand and unique goodsCovenants not to compete

How to Apply It

1
Confirm a valid contract. Check for definite terms; the contract must be certain enough to enforce.
2
Verify plaintiff's readiness. Has the plaintiff tendered or is ready to perform their side?
3
Ask: is money inadequate? Is the subject matter land or genuinely unique? If yes, equity is available.
4
Test feasibility. Can the court enforce without ongoing supervision? Beware personal services.
5
Scan for defenses. Laches, unclean hands, hardship, or unfair terms can defeat the remedy.

Example 1: Land Sale

Facts: Seller contracts to sell Buyer a specific lakefront lot for $400,000. Seller refuses to close, claiming the price was too low. Buyer is ready to pay. Can Buyer get specific performance?

Example 2: Ordinary Goods

Facts: Wholesaler agrees to deliver 500 standard office chairs to Retailer. Wholesaler breaches. Identical chairs are widely available from other suppliers at a known market price.

Example 3: Personal Services

Facts: A famous singer contracts to headline a festival but signs with a rival event. The promoter sues. May the court order the singer to perform at the original festival?

Common Mistakes

✕ Assuming It's Automatic
Specific performance is never automatic. Damages are the default; equity is the exception.
✕ Ignoring Inadequacy
Forgetting to ask whether money is inadequate. Replaceable goods almost never qualify.
✕ Forcing Personal Services
Courts will not compel an employee or artist to work. Consider an injunction instead.
✕ Skipping Defenses
Overlooking laches, unclean hands, or hardship that can bar an otherwise valid claim.

Availability Summary

Subject Matter Available? Reason
Real property (land)YesLand is unique
Unique goods / artYesIrreplaceable
Output / requirementsOftenProper UCC circumstances
Ordinary fungible goodsNoCover is adequate
Personal servicesNoServitude / supervision

Question 1 of 5

What is the most heavily tested element for specific performance?

Question 2 of 5

A seller breaches a contract to convey a specific tract of land. The buyer is ready to pay. Specific performance is:

Question 3 of 5

A supplier breaches a contract to sell 500 standard, widely available units. The buyer seeks specific performance. The court will most likely:

Question 4 of 5

A renowned chef breaches a contract to cook exclusively at a restaurant. The restaurant seeks to force the chef to work there. The court will:

Question 5 of 5

Which factor most likely defeats Buyer's claim for specific performance?

Key Takeaways

1
Damages first. Specific performance is the exception, not the default.
2
Inadequacy is key. Land and unique goods qualify; ordinary goods do not.
3
No forced labor. Personal services get an injunction, not specific performance.
4
Check defenses. Laches, unclean hands, and hardship can defeat the remedy.