Equitable Remedies
Specific Performance
When money damages won't do, courts may order a party to actually perform the contract. Learn when this powerful remedy is available.
What Are Equitable Remedies?
Courts grant two broad categories of relief. Legal remedies compensate with money: damages. Equitable remedies are non-monetary court orders that compel or forbid specific conduct.
Two Roads After a Breach
Why It Matters
The Core Rule
The single most-tested element is the inadequacy of money damages. If damages would fully compensate, the court will refuse specific performance.
The Five Elements
When Damages Are Inadequate
Specific Performance vs. Injunction
| Specific Performance | Injunction | |
|---|---|---|
| Nature of order | Compels affirmative act | Compels or forbids conduct |
| Typical use | Force completion of a sale | Restrain a competing act |
| Personal services | Generally denied | May enjoin breach indirectly |
| Common context | Land and unique goods | Covenants not to compete |
How to Apply It
Example 1: Land Sale
Facts: Seller contracts to sell Buyer a specific lakefront lot for $400,000. Seller refuses to close, claiming the price was too low. Buyer is ready to pay. Can Buyer get specific performance?
Example 2: Ordinary Goods
Facts: Wholesaler agrees to deliver 500 standard office chairs to Retailer. Wholesaler breaches. Identical chairs are widely available from other suppliers at a known market price.
Example 3: Personal Services
Facts: A famous singer contracts to headline a festival but signs with a rival event. The promoter sues. May the court order the singer to perform at the original festival?
Common Mistakes
Availability Summary
| Subject Matter | Available? | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Real property (land) | Yes | Land is unique |
| Unique goods / art | Yes | Irreplaceable |
| Output / requirements | Often | Proper UCC circumstances |
| Ordinary fungible goods | No | Cover is adequate |
| Personal services | No | Servitude / supervision |
Question 1 of 5
What is the most heavily tested element for specific performance?
Question 2 of 5
A seller breaches a contract to convey a specific tract of land. The buyer is ready to pay. Specific performance is:
Question 3 of 5
A supplier breaches a contract to sell 500 standard, widely available units. The buyer seeks specific performance. The court will most likely:
Question 4 of 5
A renowned chef breaches a contract to cook exclusively at a restaurant. The restaurant seeks to force the chef to work there. The court will:
Question 5 of 5
Buyer and Seller entered a valid written contract for the sale of a rare 1920s painting. Seller refused to deliver. Buyer was ready and able to pay the full price. However, Buyer waited eleven years after the breach to file suit, during which time the painting's value and ownership records became unclear, and Seller relied on Buyer's apparent abandonment of the claim.
Which factor most likely defeats Buyer's claim for specific performance?