Equal Protection
Scrutiny
When government draws a line between groups of people, courts apply one of three tiers of review. Learning to pick the right tier is the key to every Equal Protection question.
What Is Equal Protection?
The Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment commands that no state shall "deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws." A parallel rule binds the federal government through the Fifth Amendment's Due Process Clause.
Every Law Draws Lines
A "classification" is simply the line a law draws between who is treated one way and who is treated another. The type of line determines the level of scrutiny:
The Three Tiers of Scrutiny
Strict Scrutiny: The Toughest Test
Triggered by a suspect classification (race, national origin, alienage) or a burden on a fundamental right. To survive, the law must be:
Middle & Lowest Tiers
Who Carries the Burden?
The single most important practical difference between tiers is the burden of proof. This decides who wins close cases:
| Strict / Intermediate | Rational Basis | |
|---|---|---|
| Burden | Government | Challenger |
| Fit required | Tight | Loose |
| Typical outcome | Law often struck | Law usually upheld |
A Step-by-Step Approach
Choosing the Right Tier
Example 1: Race-Based Admissions
A state university gives an admissions preference based on the applicant's race. What tier applies?
Example 2: Gender Distinction
A state nursing program admits only women. A male applicant sues under Equal Protection.
Example 3: Age Limit
A state requires police officers to retire at age 60. A 60-year-old officer challenges the rule.
Common Mistakes
The Master Chart
| Strict | Intermediate | Rational | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Triggers | Race, origin, alienage | Gender, legitimacy | All others |
| Interest | Compelling | Important | Legitimate |
| Fit | Narrowly tailored | Substantially related | Rationally related |
| Burden | Gov't | Gov't | Challenger |
Question 1 of 5
A city ordinance gives hiring preference based on an applicant's national origin. What level of scrutiny applies?
Question 2 of 5
A state allows only men to be admitted to its all-male military college. Under intermediate scrutiny, who bears the burden, and what must they show?
Question 3 of 5
A state law sets a maximum age of 70 for licensed commercial drivers. A 70-year-old driver challenges it. Which standard governs?
Question 4 of 5
A facially neutral hiring test happens to disqualify a much higher percentage of one racial group. To trigger strict scrutiny, the plaintiff must show:
Question 5 of 5
Which combination correctly matches a tier to its required fit between means and ends?
You Can Now Pick the Tier
Equal Protection analysis always begins the same way: find the classification, choose the tier, state the standard, assign the burden, then apply.