Equal Protection
Application
Learn to classify, select the right level of scrutiny, and apply the analysis to government laws that treat groups differently.
What Is Equal Protection?
The Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment says no state shall "deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws." It does not require identical treatment — it limits when government may treat similarly situated people differently.
The Core Idea: Classifications
Three Tiers of Scrutiny
Rule: Strict Scrutiny
Rules: Intermediate & Rational Basis
Distinction: Intent vs. Impact
How to Apply the Analysis
Example 1: Age Limit
A state requires all public bus drivers to retire at age 60. A 61-year-old driver challenges the rule under the Equal Protection Clause.
Example 2: Gender Line
A state nursing school admits women only, excluding qualified male applicants. A man denied admission challenges the policy.
Example 3: Racial Set-Aside
A city reserves 10% of public contracts for businesses owned by members of a particular race. A non-minority contractor challenges the program.
Common Mistakes
Summary Table
| Strict | Intermediate | Rational | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trigger | Race, origin, alienage | Gender, legitimacy | All others |
| Interest | Compelling | Important | Legitimate |
| Fit | Necessary | Substantial | Rational |
| Burden | Government | Government | Challenger |
| Result | Usually fails | Mixed | Usually upheld |
Putting It Together
On any equal protection question, move in order: state action → classification → scrutiny → apply. The classification is the pivot — get the tier right and the rest follows mechanically.
Question 1 of 5
A state law classifies on the basis of race. What level of scrutiny applies?
Question 2 of 5
A facially neutral hiring test has a disparate impact on one race but no proof of intent. What standard applies?
Question 3 of 5
A state grants paid leave to mothers but not fathers. Which test and which interest standard apply?
Question 4 of 5
A city ordinance bars anyone over age 65 from operating a commercial taxi, citing reaction-time concerns. A 67-year-old experienced driver with a clean record sues, arguing the rule violates equal protection.
He presents evidence that many older drivers are as safe as younger ones, and that the city did no study before adopting the cap.
How will a court most likely rule?
Question 5 of 5
Under strict scrutiny and intermediate scrutiny, who bears the burden of proof?
You Can Now Apply It
You can now spot a classification, choose the correct tier of scrutiny, allocate the burden, and apply the test to reach a defensible conclusion — the full equal protection framework.