Employee
Classification
Distinguish employee from independent contractor to determine when an employer is vicariously liable for harm.
Why Classification Matters
In tort law, the label given to a worker controls whether their employer can be sued for the worker's wrongdoing. The doctrine of respondeat superior ("let the master answer") imposes vicarious liability on an employer for torts committed by an employee within the scope of employment.
Key Terms
The Two Pathways
The Core Rule: The Control Test
If the hiring party controls only the desired result, but the worker decides how to achieve it, the worker is an independent contractor. Control over the manner of performance is the single most important factor.
Factors Showing Employee Status
Employee vs. Independent Contractor
| Employee | Indep. Contractor | |
|---|---|---|
| Control over work | Manner & method | Result only |
| Tools supplied by | Employer | Worker |
| Payment | By time | By the job |
| Distinct business | No | Yes |
| Employer liable? | Yes (in scope) | Generally no |
Exceptions: When IC Liability Attaches
Even with an independent contractor, the hiring party may still be liable in three classic situations:
How to Apply the Analysis
Scope of Employment
Even for an employee, liability only attaches if the tort occurred within the scope of employment — work of the kind the employee was hired to perform, occurring within authorized time and space limits.
Worked Example 1
A delivery company gives Driver a uniform, a company truck, a daily route, and a fixed hourly wage. While making deliveries, Driver negligently strikes a pedestrian.
Worked Example 2
A homeowner hires Painter, who runs her own business, supplies her own brushes, sets her own hours, and is paid a flat fee per house. Painter negligently spills paint that injures a passerby.
Worked Example 3
A landowner hires a demolition firm (an independent contractor) to use explosives to level a building. The blast cracks a neighbor's foundation.
Common Mistakes
Decision Summary
| Situation | Result |
|---|---|
| Employee, within scope | Liable |
| Employee, frolic | Not liable |
| IC, ordinary work | Not liable |
| IC, inherently dangerous | Liable |
| IC, non-delegable duty | Liable |
Question 1 of 5
Under the control test, which factor is the single most important in classifying a worker?
Question 2 of 5
A company hires a plumber who runs her own business, brings her own tools, and is paid a flat fee per job. She negligently floods a home. The company is most likely:
Question 3 of 5
Which is an exception under which a hiring party may be liable for an independent contractor's torts?
Question 4 of 5
An employee makes a small detour to grab coffee on his delivery route and causes an accident. The employer is most likely:
Question 5 of 5
A contract expressly calls the worker an "independent contractor," but the company sets her hours, route, and methods and pays her hourly. For liability purposes she is best treated as: